Power Generator Delaying Dedicated Transmission Line Liable For Intervening Transmission Tariff Under Section 10 Electricity Act: Supreme Court

20 November 2026 4:22 PM

By: kapil


NEW DELHI — Setting aside the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity's ruling, the Supreme Court bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran held on November 18, 2026, that a power generating company failing to commission its mandatory dedicated transmission line within the stipulated schedule is legally bound under Section 10 of the Electricity Act, 2003, to bear transmission charges for intervening Loop-In Loop-Out assets utilized to evacuate power.

The dispute arose after Power Grid Corporation of India Limited commissioned two Line-In Line-Out assets on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai 400kV line in January 2015 to connect the Tuticorin Pooling Station. While the generating company evacuated power through interim arrangements without commissioning its mandatory Dedicated Transmission Line until October 27, 2016, APTEL denied transmission charges to the Central Transmission Utility on the premise that upstream lines were incomplete and the assets lacked beneficial use. Aggrieved by APTEL's decisions remanding the approved Commercial Operation Date and denying non-PoC recovery, PGCIL appealed before the Supreme Court.

The questions before the Court were whether the transmission licensee was entitled to transmission tariff for the two LILOs as part of the statutory planning under Section 29(4) of the Electricity Act and the Bulk Power Transmission Agreement; whether APTEL erred in re-opening the Commercial Operation Date approved by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission under Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the Tariff Regulations; and whether the delay in constructing the Dedicated Transmission Line enabled the liability for the disputed period to be mulcted on the generating company.

Examining the statutory layout governing generation and inter-state transmission, the Court underscored the statutory duties saddled upon generating companies under the regulatory architecture.

Generating companies bear statutory obligation to construct dedicated evacuation infrastructure under Section 10

The bench observed that Section 10 of the Electricity Act mandates generating companies to establish, operate, and maintain generating stations, tie-lines, sub-stations, and dedicated transmission lines in accordance with statutory standards. A Dedicated Transmission Line, defined under Section 2(16), constitutes a point-to-point electric supply line required to link generating stations to transmission networks or pooling points, making evacuation lines an uncompromising legal obligation of the power producer.

The Court scrutinized the physics of power evacuation and rejected the generating company's contention that electricity seamlessly flowed directly to Madurai through the path of least resistance without utilizing the intermediary pooling network.

Interception by permanent LILOs established beneficial use and routing through the pooling hub

The bench observed that once PGCIL's permanent LILOs were installed on the Tuticorin JV-Madurai line, any power evacuated into the circuit was necessarily intercepted at the Line-In, routed into the Tuticorin Pooling Station for voltage stabilization through bus reactors, and evacuated via the Line-Out. The Court pointed out that electricity naturally moved into the Tuticorin Pooling Station as its path of least resistance, thereby refuting the generator's denial of operational utilization.

Addressing the regulatory mechanics governing the declaration of Commercial Operation Date, the Court held that APTEL completely misapplied Regulation 4(3)(ii) of the Tariff Regulations, 2014.

RLDC trial certification validly establishes regular service and Commercial Operation Date under Tariff Regulations

The Court noted that Regulation 4(3)(ii) applies strictly where an element is prevented from regular service due to external default, which was wholly inapplicable because power evacuation commenced seamlessly and the LILO assets entered regular service upon RLDC trial operation certification and CEA safety clearances. The Court held that APTEL committed a manifest error by demanding a redetermination of the Commercial Operation Date that had already been properly confirmed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission.

The bench reiterated settled administrative law principles concerning the broad adjudicatory and regulatory repository vested in electricity commissions under the statutory framework.

Absence of specific subordinate regulations does not restrict regulatory recovery against a defaulting entity

Relying on Energy Watchdog and PGCIL v. MPPTCL, the Court held that the regulatory powers of CERC under Section 79(1) of the Electricity Act operate independently and empower the regulator to reasonably mulct liabilities on a defaulting entity to avoid uncompensated utilization of transmission infrastructure. Consequently, the delay on the part of the generating company in commissioning its dedicated lines directly justified the non-PoC bilateral transmission charges cast upon it.

The Supreme Court set aside the impugned orders of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity and restored the tariff order of the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, holding the power generator liable for the transmission charges for the period between the commissioning of the LILOs and the commissioning of the dedicated line.

Date of Decision: November 18, 2026

Latest Legal News