-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
"The time line of 30 days is not mandatory, though it deserves to be observed. There is no statutory mandate to decide within a period of thirty days and so no statutory right to be enforced by issuance of a direction to the learned Court." Observing that the thirty-day period prescribed under Order 39 Rule 3A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is directory and not mandatory, the Andhra Pradesh High Court bench of Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari on November 6, 2026, held that litigants cannot assert an enforceable statutory right to secure directions from constitutional courts for the time-bound adjudication of interlocutory injunction applications.
The dispute arose after the respondent-plaintiff instituted an original suit for permanent injunction and obtained an ex-parte ad-interim temporary injunction against the petitioner on September 12, 2025. The petitioner filed a counter-affidavit on February 12, 2026, but the interlocutory application remained pending before the trial court due to multiple adjournments granted to the plaintiff to file a reply. Aggrieved by the non-disposal of the application, the petitioner approached the High Court via a Civil Revision Petition seeking a direction to the trial court for expeditious disposal.
Whether the thirty-day disposal timeline stipulated under Order 39 Rule 3A of the CPC is mandatory, and whether the High Court can routinely issue directions fixing a time-bound schedule for subordinate courts in the absence of exceptional circumstances?
Examining the statutory text of Order 39 Rule 3A CPC, the High Court observed that while the provision requires courts to make an effort to decide ex-parte injunction applications within thirty days and record reasons if unable to do so, it does not impose a mandatory obligation.
Order 39 Rule 3A CPC creates a procedural guideline rather than an absolute statutory mandate
Justice Tilhari emphasized that the legislative phrasing of the provision precludes it from operating as an inflexible deadline. The Court clarified that the provision merely calls upon the subordinate court to strive towards deciding the application within thirty days.
"However, I am of the further view that the time limit of 30 days is not mandatory. The expression used is 'the Court shall make an endeavour' to dispose of within that period and if it is not so possible, it shall record the reasons," the Court observed.
Subordinate courts granting time for pleadings cannot be accused of failing to make statutory endeavours
Upon reviewing the trial court docket orders from August 5, 2026 to October 5, 2026, the bench noticed that the trial court was routinely taking up the case and granting time to the plaintiff to place a reply on record.
The Court held that such procedural progress demonstrates that the subordinate court was actively making an endeavour to address the application, dispelling the assertion of judicial inaction.
"Therefore, it cannot be said that the Court is not making endeavour to dispose of the injunction matter. The time line of 30 days is not mandatory, though it deserves to be observed. There is no statutory mandate to decide within a period of thirty days and so no statutory right to be enforced by issuance of a direction to the learned Court," the bench observed.
Constitutional courts must refrain from fixing time-bound schedules for subordinate court proceedings
Relying on the Constitution Bench ruling of the Supreme Court in High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of Uttar Pradesh, the Court reiterated that constitutional courts should refrain from fixing time-bound schedules for trial courts in the ordinary course.
The bench noted that the Supreme Court in Sangram Sadashiv Suryavanshi v. State of Maharashtra explicitly cautioned High Courts against routinely passing directions for expeditious disposal without establishing exceptional circumstances.
"No exceptional circumstance has been shown to issue direction as requested in the CRP. The party desirous of expeditious disposal, should approach the Court concerned where the matter is pending," the Court noted while declining to issue a mandamus to the trial judge.
The High Court accordingly disposed of the Civil Revision Petition without issuing any direction to the trial court, granting liberty to the petitioner to approach the concerned trial court directly to seek an expeditious hearing.
Date of Decision: November 6, 2026