Absence of Videography Alone Not Sufficient For Bail When Custody is Less Than a Year: Delhi High Court Refuses Bail in Commercial Quantity Heroin Use of Permitted Synthetic Colour in Dal Masur Still Constitutes Adulteration: Punjab & Haryana High Court Uphold Conviction Penalty Must Not Result in Civil Death of Professionals: Delhi High Court Reduces Two-Year Suspension of Insolvency Professional, Citing Disproportionate Punishment Right of Cross-Examination is Statutory, Cannot Be Denied When Documents Are Exhibited Later: Chhattisgarh High Court Allows Re-Cross-Examination Compounding after Adjudication is Impermissible under FEMA: Calcutta High Court Declines Post-Adjudication Compounding Plea Tears of a Child Speak Louder Than Words: Bombay HC Confirms Life Term for Man Who Raped 4-Year-Old Alleged Dowry Death After Forced Remarriage: Allahabad High Court Finds No Evidence of Strangulation or Demand “Even If Executant Has No Title, Registrar Must Register the Document If Formalities Are Met” — Supreme Court  Declares Tamil Nadu's Rule 55A(i) Ultra Vires the Registration Act, 1908 Res Judicata Is Not Optional – It’s Public Policy: Supreme Court Slams SEBI for Passing Second Final Order in Fraud Case Against Vital Communications Ltd A Person Has Died… Insurance Company Cannot Escape Liability Without Proving Policy Violation: Supreme Court Slams High Court for Exonerating Insurer in Fatal Accident Case Calling Someone by Caste Name Is Not Enough – It Must Be Publicly Done to Attract SC/ST Act: Supreme Court Acquits All in Jharkhand Land Dispute Case Broken Promises Don’t Make Rape – Mature Adults in Long-Term Relationships Must Accept Responsibility: Supreme Court Quashes Rape Case Against NRI Man Every Broken Relationship Can’t Be Branded Rape: Supreme Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Retired Judge Accused of Sexual Exploitation on Promise of Marriage No Evidence, No Motive, Not Even Proof of Murder: Supreme Court Slams Conviction, Acquits Man Accused of Killing Wife After Two Years of Marriage You Can’t Assume Silence Is Consent: Supreme Court Sends Back ₹46 Lakh Insurance Dispute to NCDRC for Fresh Determination “Voyage Must Start and End Before Monsoon Sets In — But What If That’s Practically Impossible?” SC Rules Against Insurance Company in Shipping Dispute No Criminal Case Can Be Built on a Land Deal That’s Three Decades Old Without Specific Allegations: Supreme Court Upholds Quashing of FIR Against Ex-JK Housing Chief Just Giving a Call for Protest Doesn’t Make One Criminally Liable - Rail Roko Protest Quashed Against KCR Ex-CM: Telangana High Court Ends 13-Year-Old Proceedings for 2011 Telangana Agitation This Is Not a Case of Greed Simplicitor but a Celebration of Fraud: Karnataka High Court Grants Specific Performance, Slams Vendor for Violating Court Orders Limitation Period Under Section 18-A of Rent Act Mandatory, Delay Not Condonable – Punjab & Haryana High Court Upholds NRI Landlord's Eviction Against Tenant Custom Department Cannot Revive Time-Barred Show Cause Notices After Seven Years Without Jurisdiction: Gujarat High Court Quashes Customs Notices to JBS Exports Public Property Cannot Be Managed Privately for Decades — Fair Price Shops in Hospitals Must Be Allotted by Auction: Jammu & Kashmir High Court Registered Sale Deed Alone Does Not Dismantle Prior Security Interest: Gauhati High Court Rejects Buyer’s Writ Against SARFAESI Action, Cites Expanded Statutory Definition Old OBC Certificates Won’t Work — Supreme Court Says Cut-Off Date Is Final in Rajasthan Civil Judge Exams

Issue Of Res Judicata Determined From The Statements Made In The Plaint Not Materials Beyond The Plaint Itself – P&H HC

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


In a recent ruling, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has affirmed the rejection of a plaint based on the principle of res judicata. The judgement, delivered on August 4, 2023, by Justice Vikram Aggarwal, dealt with a civil revision petition challenging the dismissal of an application to reject a plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC (Code of Civil Procedure). The judge reiterated that the issue of res judicata should be determined solely from the statements made in the plaint and should not involve consideration of materials beyond the plaint itself.

The case involved a suit for declaration of ownership and related claims. The plaintiffs claimed an oral partition among brothers in an earlier suit and subsequently filed a fresh suit seeking ownership declaration. The defendant moved an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, seeking the rejection of the plaint on res judicata grounds, invoking a previous judgement on similar issues.

Justice Vikram Aggarwal, while examining the principles of rejecting plaints, emphasized, "Order 7 Rule 11(d) of CPC provides that the plaint shall be rejected 'where the suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any law'. Hence, in order to decide whether the suit is barred by any law, it is the statement in the plaint which will have to be construed." The judge reiterated that the issue of res judicata should be determined solely from the statements made in the plaint and should not involve consideration of materials beyond the plaint itself.

The Court further referenced a recent Supreme Court judgement, *Srihari Hanumandass Totala Vs. Hemant Vithal Kamat and others*, which articulated that the rule of res judicata does not strike at the root of the court's jurisdiction but is based on the principle of estoppel by judgment to ensure finality in litigation. The judgement also highlighted that for invoking Order 7 Rule 11(d) CPC, no additional evidence can be taken into account beyond the statements in the plaint.

While upholding the rejection of the plaint, Justice Vikram Aggarwal granted liberty to the petitioner to raise the issue of maintainability before the trial court, emphasizing that the trial court should consider framing a preliminary issue regarding the plea of res judicata. The judgement is poised to have significant implications for cases where res judicata is cited as a ground for rejection of plaints, establishing a clearer framework for evaluating such matters.

Date of Decision: 04.08.2023

Ishwar vs Bhim Singh and others        

Similar News