-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
"Custody of a child, physical or legal, is held for the child; it is not a lever in the dispute between the parents. The parent with whom the child lives has his daily care, but that care carries no veto over treatment he needs." Madras High Court, in a significant ruling dated 30 September 2026, held that when parents are unable to reach a consensus on the medical treatment of a minor child, the court—acting as parens patriae—has the authority to mandate a treatment plan based on independent, expert assessment.
Presiding over the matter, Dr. Justice A.D. Maria Clete observed that the welfare of the child is paramount and transcends the personal disputes or preferences of the parents, stating, "It is not a refereeing exercise between the parents, but to decide on independent advice what the child needs and to see that it is done."
The dispute arose between a father residing in the USA and a mother residing in Thanjavur regarding the custody and developmental treatment of their eight-year-old son, who was diagnosed with mild autism and developmental language disorder. While both parents sought the child's best interests, they remained locked in a conflict over where and how the child should receive specialized therapy, leading to multiple interlocutory applications. The court intervened to appoint an Advocate Commissioner and a multidisciplinary medical team from a government centre of excellence to assess the child’s requirements and bypass the deadlock created by the parents' conflicting claims.
The primary question before the court was whether it possessed the jurisdiction to mandate a specific medical treatment program for a minor residing outside the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the High Court. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether a parent’s objection to a court-mandated treatment plan could be sustained on the grounds of potential psychological distress to an autistic child or an alleged lack of jurisdiction. The court was also tasked with defining the role of the judiciary when both parents use the child’s medical condition as a leverage point in custody litigation.
Jurisdiction Under Clause 17 of Letters Patent
The court firmly rejected the mother’s jurisdictional challenge, noting that she had previously invoked the court's jurisdiction for her own relief and participated in multiple mediation proceedings. Relying on Section 3 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, and established precedents including the five-judge bench decision in S. Annapoorni v. K. Vijay, the court held that its parens patriae power over infants extends to minors residing within the former Presidency of Madras, regardless of their current residence within the state.
Court Assumes Parens Patriae Role
The court emphasized that in custody battles, parents often speak for their own interests rather than the child's. To bridge this, the court appointed an Advocate Commissioner as its "eyes and hands" and a legal aid counsel to represent the child exclusively. The bench observed that the child’s welfare is a distinct interest that may not coincide with the legal strategies of either parent, and once the court assumes supervision, the choice of medical protocol is no longer a matter of parental contest.
Expert-Led Treatment Prioritized
Addressing the child's specific diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder and developmental language disorder, the court noted that the expert-led multidisciplinary team identified needs that the parents' privately consulted doctors had missed or failed to address. The bench ruled that the child required a structured, intensive one-month program in Chennai, followed by continued therapy in Thanjavur, to ensure the mother is adequately trained to support the child’s daily development.
"The parent with whom the child lives has his daily care, but that care carries no veto over treatment he needs."
Distinguishing Precedents on Relocation
The court distinguished this case from Helan Janani v. Arunkumar and Prakash Fakira Dhanore v. Sushmita Bora, noting that those cases involved the permanent uprooting of a child from the mother’s custody. In this instance, the custody remains with the mother, who is directed to accompany the child for the treatment program. The court affirmed that the child’s routine is being supplemented rather than destroyed, and the mother's concern regarding social disclosure is protected by court-ordered confidentiality.
Final Directions and Oversight
The court directed the father to bear all expenses associated with the treatment and ordered that the child be prepared for the transition by the Advocate Commissioner and legal aid counsel in a gentle, age-appropriate manner. The court mandated that the treatment plan be treated as a priority, warning both parties that any obstruction to the medical program would result in further judicial intervention. The matter is listed for review on 23 October 2026, by which time the initial implementation of the medical program must be reported.
Date of Decision: 30 September 2026