High Court, As A Constitutional Court Of Record, Possesses The Inherent Power To Correct Its Own Record: Bombay High Court High Court of Uttarakhand Acquits Defendants in High-Profile Murder Case, Cites Lack of Evidence In Cases of Financial Distress, Imposing A Mandatory Deposit Under Negotiable Instruments Act May Jeopardize Appellant’s Right To Appeal: Rajasthan High Court Patna High Court Acquits Accused, Questions “Capacity of Victim to Make Coherent Statement” with 100% Burn Injuries High Court of Himachal Pradesh Dismisses Bail Plea in ₹200 Crore Scholarship Scam: Rajdeep Singh Case Execution of Conveyance Ends Arbitration Clause; Appeal for Arbitration Rejected: Bombay High Court Allahabad High Court Denies Tax Refund for Hybrid Vehicle Purchased Before Electric Vehicle Exemption Policy Entering A Room with Someone Cannot, By Any Stretch Of Imagination, Be Considered Consent For Sexual Intercourse: Bombay High Court No Specific Format Needed for Dying Declaration, Focus on Mental State and Voluntariness: Calcutta High Court Delhi High Court Allows Direct Appeal Under DVAT Act Without Tribunal Reference for Pre-2005 Tax Periods NDPS | Mere Registration of Cases Does Not Override Presumption of Innocence: Himachal Pradesh High Court No Previous Antecedents and No Communal Tension: High Court Grants Bail in Caste-Based Abuse Case Detention of Petitioner Would Amount to Pre-Trial Punishment: Karnataka High Court Grants Bail in Dowry Harassment Case Loss of Confidence Must Be Objectively Proven to Deny Reinstatement: Kerala High Court Reinstates Workman After Flawed Domestic Enquiry Procedural lapses should not deny justice: Andhra High Court Enhances Compensation in Motor Accident Case Canteen Subsidy Constitutes Part of Dearness Allowance Under EPF Act: Gujarat High Court Concurrent Findings Demonstrate Credibility – Jharkhand High Court Affirms Conviction in Cheating Case 125 Cr.P.C | Financial responsibility towards dependents cannot be shirked due to personal obligations: Punjab and Haryana High Court Mere Acceptance of Money Without Proof of Demand is Not Sufficient to Establish Corruption Charges Gujrat High Court Evidence Insufficient to Support Claims: Orissa High Court Affirms Appellate Court’s Reversal in Wrongful Confinement and Defamation Case Harmonious Interpretation of PWDV Act and Senior Citizens Act is Crucial: Kerala High Court in Domestic Violence Case

Bail Cannot Be Granted Unless Twin Conditions of Proving No Guilt and No Likelihood of Re-offending Are Met Under MCOCA: Delhi High Court

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


The Delhi High Court has rejected the bail application of Dheerpal alias Kana, accused under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) and various other serious offenses. The judgment, delivered by Hon'ble Justice Navin Chawla on May 30, 2024, underscores the stringent scrutiny required under MCOCA and the significant role of the accused in the alleged crime syndicate. The Court highlighted the flight risk posed by the applicant and the prima facie case established by the prosecution.

Background: Dheerpal alias Kana filed a bail application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking release in connection with FIR No. 531/2015 registered at Police Station Najafgarh, Delhi. The FIR involves allegations under Sections 3 and 4 of the MCOCA, Section 25 of the Arms Act, and various sections of the Indian Penal Code, including murder, extortion, and robbery. The prosecution alleges that Dheerpal is a key associate of the organized crime syndicate led by Vikas Gulia alias Vikas Langarpuria, involved in multiple serious crimes across Delhi and Haryana.

Role of Accused in Organized Crime: The Court examined substantial evidence linking the applicant to an organized crime syndicate led by Vikas Gulia alias Vikas Langarpuria. The prosecution presented multiple FIRs and investigation reports substantiating the applicant’s involvement in serious offenses, including murder, extortion, and robbery. "The applicant's previous conduct and risk of absconding cannot be ignored," Justice Chawla noted. The applicant's involvement in ten cases, with three cases alongside Vikas Langarpuria, reinforced the prosecution's claim.

Legal Standards for Bail under MCOCA: The judgment delved into the legal framework of MCOCA, emphasizing the strict conditions under Section 21(4). The Court reiterated that bail cannot be granted unless the applicant meets the twin conditions of proving no guilt and no likelihood of re-offending. "The applicant has failed to satisfy these criteria," the Court observed, referencing the applicant’s absconding behavior and subsequent involvement in further crimes during interim bail.

Existence of Prima Facie Case under MCOCA: Justice Chawla highlighted the prima facie case against the applicant under MCOCA, referencing the evidence of continuing unlawful activity and the applicant's role in the organized crime syndicate. "The applicant's involvement in an organized crime syndicate is supported by multiple chargesheets and cognizance taken by the Court," the judgment stated. The Court noted the necessity of considering the reasons for acquittal or discharge in related cases, which often stemmed from witness intimidation, a key factor in organized crime.

"The balance of competing rights in this case can only be achieved by ensuring an expedited trial," Justice Chawla remarked. "The evidence linking the applicant to the organized crime syndicate is substantial, and his previous conduct indicates a significant flight risk."

Decision: The Delhi High Court’s decision to deny bail to Dheerpal alias Kana underscores the judiciary's commitment to stringent scrutiny under MCOCA and the importance of addressing organized crime comprehensively. By directing the Trial Court to expedite proceedings, the judgment aims to balance the rights of the accused with societal interests. This decision is expected to have significant implications for future cases involving organized crime, reinforcing the legal framework designed to combat such offenses.

Date of Decision: May 30, 2024

Dheerpal Alias Kana vs. State Govt of NCT of Delhi

Similar News