Article 19(1)(c) Inapplicable When Police Associations Are Formed By Executive Order With Automatic Rank-Based Membership: Kerala High Court Upholds State Restructuring Under Article 33

20 November 2026 4:18 PM

By: sayum


"The associations that we are concerned with in these appeals are not those in which a member, or the association itself, can claim any right traceable to Article 19(1)(c); if that be so, the restructuring exercise undertaken by the State Executive cannot be seen as infringing the rights of the writ petitioners under Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India," Kerala High Court

Kerala High Court on Thursday held that police personnel cannot assert a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution of India to form or continue associations where such bodies are executive creations whose membership is automatically determined by rank rather than voluntary individual agency, a Division Bench comprising Dr. Justice A.K. Jayasankaran Nambiar and Mrs. Justice Preeta A.K. delivered the judgment. Setting aside a Single Judge verdict, the Bench held that the State Government retains absolute policy competence under Article 162 of the Constitution and Section 109 of the Kerala Police Act, 2011 to reorganize, merge, or restructure police associations in the interest of administrative efficiency.

The litigation originated from an executive order issued on July 27, 2026, wherein the Government of Kerala restructured three recognized police associations established under a 1979 framework by abolishing the Kerala Police Officers' Association and reallocating its membership between the Kerala Police Association and the Kerala Police Senior Officers' Association. Aggrieved by this unilateral restructuring, members and office-bearers approached the High Court contending that the abolition violated their fundamental rights under Article 19(1)(c) and bypassed statutory requirements under Rule 8 of the Police Forces (Restriction of Rights) Rules, 1966. A Single Judge quashed the government order, holding that the State could not alter an association's composition without member consent, prompting the State and affected personnel to prefer writ appeals.

Whether members of a disciplined police force possess an enforceable fundamental right under Article 19(1)(c) read with Article 33 of the Constitution of India in respect of associations created by executive orders? Whether the State Government possesses executive power under Article 162 and Section 109 of the Kerala Police Act to unilaterally restructure and abolish recognized police associations without adhering to internal bye-law amendment procedures?

Constitutional Scheme Under Article 33 Restricts Fundamental Rights Of Police Personnel

Examining the interplay between Articles 19(1)(c), 19(4), and Article 33 of the Constitution along with the Police Forces (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1966, the Court observed that Article 33 operates as an explicit exception to the universal applicability of fundamental rights. The Bench noted that Parliament's authority to abridge fundamental freedoms of armed forces and police personnel charged with maintaining public order is unqualified when aimed at preserving discipline and ensuring proper discharge of sovereign duties.

The Court emphasized that an individual joining the police force implicitly accepts a circumscribed code of conduct, meaning the content of their associative rights stands drastically curtailed when compared to ordinary citizens. The Bench underscored that where statutory or constitutional restrictions apply, constitutional courts generally refrain from probing the propriety or policy wisdom of the regulation.

Lack Of Voluntary Agency Excludes Article 19(1)(c) Protections

Analyzing the origin of the recognized police bodies in Kerala, the Bench pointed out that the associations were conceived directly by the State Government in 1979 based on rank classification, rather than through voluntary assembly by personnel. Membership was entirely automatic and rank-dependent, transitioning automatically as an officer advanced in service without requiring any voluntary act or agreement.

Relying on established apex court jurisprudence, the Bench ruled that fundamental rights are intrinsically individual rights exercised through voluntary human agency. Because individual agency was conspicuously absent in the establishment of and enrolment into these departmental associations, neither the associations nor their members could claim any fundamental right traceable to Article 19(1)(c) to resist restructuring.

State Executive Retains Broad Policy Competence To Reorganize Police Bodies

Addressing the binding nature of the associations' bye-laws, the Division Bench ruled that internal regulations framed pursuant to executive permission merely govern functional administration and electoral mechanics. Such bye-laws cannot elevate executive-created bodies to autonomous entities capable of divesting the Government of its ultimate supervisory and restructuring authority under Article 162 of the Constitution.

The Bench observed that the power to permit the formation and continuation of police associations carries with it the ancillary executive power to restructure them to align with modern cadre revisions, including the Grade Promotion Scheme. Testing the decision on settled standards of judicial review, the Court concluded that regrouping constabulary grades into one association and directly recruited officers into another was a rational policy choice aimed at enhancing service representation.

Allowing the writ appeals, the Division Bench set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge and dismissed the original writ petitions, thereby fully restoring and upholding the validity of the State Government Order dated July 27, 2026.

Date of Decision: November 12, 2026

 

Latest Legal News