Arbitration Act | Award Cannot Be Modified Merely Because Additional Work Exceeds 70% Of Contract Value Or Debtor Is State Entity: Supreme Court

20 November 2026 4:21 PM

By: kapil


"There can hence be no interference caused to the quantum of claim decided by the Arbitrator, based on valid material, merely for the reason that the award debtor is a Government entity and that the quantum appears to be excessive without any substantiation for such a ground being raised against the award itself," Supreme Court.

NEW DELHI — The Supreme Court on November 18, 2026, held that an appellate court exercising jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, cannot modify an arbitral award or arbitrarily halve the quantified claim on a subjective presumption that additional work bills exceeding 70% of the original contract value "shocks the conscience" of the court. A Bench comprising Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran ruled that the phrase "conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice" cannot be deployed on mere lip service where the arbitral tribunal has adjudicated claims on cogent evidence and without patent illegality.

The dispute originated from a contract awarded by the Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata to M/s Marino Dredgeco Limited for dredging the riverbed and shores to construct an approach channel and basin at Sagar Island. Adverse force majeure weather conditions, coupled with severe siltation and discrepancies in soil data supplied by the Port Trust, necessitated repeated and identical re-dredging works, which were instructed via official correspondence.

Following completion of the project, the contractor initiated arbitration for unpaid additional works, and the sole arbitrator rendered an award in favour of the contractor based on joint measurements and pre- and post-work levels. The award was subsequently affirmed by a Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. However, on an appeal under Section 37, the Division Bench slashed the awarded quantum to 50% and reduced the interest rate to 6%, reasoning that an additional work claim exceeding 70% of the original contract shocked its conscience, even while finding that the award suffered from neither insufficiency of evidence nor patent illegality.

Whether an appellate court under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, possesses the jurisdiction to modify an arbitral award by reducing the quantified sum solely because the claims for additional works exceed 70% of the original contract value?

Whether an arbitral award can be partially set aside or modified under the doctrine of "shocking the conscience" or "conflict with basic notions of morality or justice" without substantive patent illegality, merely because the award debtor is a State instrumentality?

Court's Observations And Judgment

The Supreme Court observed that the Division Bench of the High Court committed a fundamental jurisdictional error by modifying the award based purely on surmise. The Bench noted that the Division Bench had itself recorded that the award was not based on "no evidence" or "insufficient evidence", nor was it perverse, patently illegal, or opposed to the fundamental policy of Indian law.

Expressions like 'shocking the conscience' cannot be applied mechanically

Reiterating the limits of court interference, the Bench highlighted that post-2015 amendments, courts cannot review an arbitral award on merits under the guise of examining whether the arbitrator adopted a judicial approach. The Bench underscored that terms like "public policy" or "morality and justice" require rigorous threshold satisfaction.

"However, the words are not to be applied on a mere lip service and there should be a substantive reason which blatantly and patently brings forth the conflict with the most basic notions of morality or justice, resulting in the conscience of the Court being shocked."

Citing its prior ruling in Somdatt Builders–NCC–NEC (JV) v. National Highways Authority of India, the Court reiterated that Section 37 confers an extremely limited jurisdiction. The Bench pointed out that an appellate court cannot set aside or modify an arbitral award by merely invoking talismanic phrases such as "opposed to public policy", "patent illegality", or "shocking the conscience" without analyzing the nature of the additional works executed.

Re-dredging was necessitated by force majeure and faulty soil data

Addressing the factual matrix, the Supreme Court noted that the initial contract involved dredging to establish a functional navigation channel, while the additional work was re-dredging necessitated by 100% siltation, force majeure conditions, and the Port Trust's failure to provide accurate soil constitution data or construct protective retaining walls.

The Court held that the work of re-dredging was identical in nature to the original contract. Consequently, the fact that bills raised on valid measurements for necessary additional works exceeded 70% of the original contract value could never be an independent legal ground to brand the arbitral award as contrary to justice or morality.

Arbitral awards cannot be severed into arbitrary silos

The Bench referred to the Constitution Bench judgment in Gayatri Balasamy v. M/s ISG Novasoft Technologies Limited, which settled that while courts have the power to set aside awards partially, such severance is permissible only when valid and invalid portions are legally and practically separable.

"In the present case, there is no question of severance of the award into separate silos since the quantification was made in accordance with valid measurements and the invoices raised by the contractor. The Division Bench considering the application under Section 37 has not looked into the measurement or the invoices, which in any event, would be an exercise of adjudication on merits, clearly prohibited under the Act of 1996."

The Court emphasized that the measurements and invoices formed an integrated whole arising out of the re-dredging work, making it impermissible for the High Court to arbitrarily compartmentalize or halve the quantified sum without an inquiry into merits—an exercise expressly barred under the statutory framework.

State entities enjoy no special dispensation or immunity in arbitral claims

The Supreme Court sternly disapproved of the High Court's inclination to reduce the award amount merely because the award debtor was a public authority. Relying on Pam Developments Private Ltd. v. State of West Bengal, the Bench reiterated that all parties to an arbitration must be treated with strict equality.

The Court held that Government entities cannot claim special treatment or immunity from money decrees validly rendered by arbitral tribunals. A court cannot interfere with the quantum of a claim adjudicated on relevant material solely because the award debtor is a State instrumentality and the quantum appears substantial.

Holding that the Division Bench exceeded the statutory confines of Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, the Supreme Court set aside the impugned High Court judgment. The appeal filed by the contractor was allowed, and the original arbitral award dated November 3, 2003, was restored in its entirety. The cross-appeal preferred by the Port of Kolkata was accordingly disposed of.

Date of Decision: November 18, 2026

Latest Legal News