Criminal Law - Murder – Credibility of Eyewitnesses – Related Witnesses' Testimony Found Doubtful – Four accused were convicted under Section 302 IPC for allegedly stabbing the deceased in a public place – Held: Evidence of PWs 4 and 5, who were closely related to the deceased and chance witnesses, was found unreliable due to inconsistencies, lack of clarity on presence...
Criminal Law – Conviction under Section 324 IPC – Voluntarily causing hurt by knife – Conviction Upheld – The appellant was convicted by the Trial Court for assaulting PW-1 with a knife, causing incised injury on the wrist – Conviction affirmed by High Court in revision – Defence of false implication due to animosity and non-recovery of knife rejected – He...
NDPS Act – Section 50 – Search of Bag Not Equivalent to Personal Search – Non-compliance with Section 50 Not Fatal – Held that a bag, briefcase or container carried by a person is not part of the human body and does not fall within the meaning of “person” under Section 50 – Therefore, the procedural safeguards under Section 50 are not attracted when a bag ...
Criminal Law – Abetment of Suicide – Section 306 IPC – Husband convicted for abetting wife’s suicide and mother-in-law convicted under Section 498A IPC – Wife consumed poison at her parental home – Allegation only that husband told wife not to put sindoor of his name on her head – No other evidence of cruelty or instigation – Held: Mere utterance wit...
Criminal Law – Common Object – Murder – Section 149 IPC – Appellants convicted for double murder arising out of long-standing family enmity – Deceased persons were attacked in two successive incidents by a group armed with deadly weapons – Trial court and High Court found all accused shared common object and participated in the crime – Held: Even in absenc...
Criminal Law – Abuse of Process – Quashing of Proceedings – Bank officers encashed guarantors’ FDRs after loan default – Guarantor filed complaint under Sections 409, 422, 426 and 120B IPC alleging conspiracy and breach of trust – FIR against borrower and guarantors already lodged by bank – Held: Complaint was a counter-blast and lacked any specific allega...
Criminal Law – Sentencing – Sections 307, 333 IPC – Undue Leniency by High Court – Order reducing sentence to period undergone set aside – Trial court convicted one accused under Sections 307 & 330 IPC and the other under Sections 307/34 & 333/34 IPC for assault on a constable with sharp weapon on a railway platform – High Court reduced sentence to about...
Negotiable Instruments Act – Section 138 – Ingredients – Dishonour of Cheque – Cheque dishonoured with remark “reported lost by drawer” – No allegation of insufficiency of funds – Complainant issued statutory notice and filed complaint – Appellant sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC – Held: Penal liability under Section 138 arises only...
Criminal Law – Death Penalty – Rarest of Rare – Commutation – Bachan Singh Doctrine Reaffirmed – Appellant convicted of kidnapping and dismembering a friend’s body after murder for ransom – Sessions and High Courts imposed death penalty considering brutality and role of mastermind – Supreme Court holds that mitigating factors such as youth, no past c...
Criminal Law – Murder Conviction – Acquittal – Appellants convicted under Sections 302, 201 and 120-B IPC for the murder of a 10-year-old boy based on circumstantial evidence – Trial Court relied on testimonies of PW-2 (claimed to overhear a conspiracy), PW-3 and PW-4 (last seen witnesses) – High Court affirmed the conviction holding the chain of circumstances complet...