Criminal Law – Dowry Death – Presumption under Section 113B Evidence Act – Marriage Date Dispute – Appellant convicted under Sections 304B and 498A IPC for causing death of wife by burns – Trial Court held marriage occurred in 1987 and drew presumption of dowry death – Supreme Court held marriage likely occurred in 1983 as per voter list evidence, making Section...
Criminal Law – Murder – Dying Declaration – Victim named appellants Dilip Dey and Manoj Singh as shooters in statement recorded by police officer in presence of doctor and relatives – Statement corroborated by brothers of deceased (PWs 5 and 7) – Medical officer (PW9) confirmed victim was conscious – Objection to lack of medical certificate of mental fitness rej...
Criminal Law – Abetment of Suicide – Section 306 IPC – Husband convicted for abetting wife’s suicide and mother-in-law convicted under Section 498A IPC – Wife consumed poison at her parental home – Allegation only that husband told wife not to put sindoor of his name on her head – No other evidence of cruelty or instigation – Held: Mere utterance wit...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR - Medical Negligence – Criminal Liability – IPC Section 304A – Civil vs. Criminal Standard – FIR alleged death of patient due to empty oxygen cylinder and negligence of doctors – Issue: whether such facts make out offence under Section 304A IPC – Held: For criminal liability, negligence must be “gross” or of a ver...
Criminal Law – Murder Conviction – Acquittal – Appellants convicted under Sections 302, 201 and 120-B IPC for the murder of a 10-year-old boy based on circumstantial evidence – Trial Court relied on testimonies of PW-2 (claimed to overhear a conspiracy), PW-3 and PW-4 (last seen witnesses) – High Court affirmed the conviction holding the chain of circumstances complet...
Criminal Law - Murder – Section 302, 34 IPC – Circumstantial Evidence and Last-Seen Theory – Conviction Set Aside – The appellant was convicted for murder based on being last seen with the deceased and an extra-judicial confession – Held: Last-seen circumstance without a complete chain of evidence cannot justify conviction, particularly with time-gap between deceased ...
Criminal Contempt of Court – Scandalising the Judiciary – News Report based on Speech – Gross Contempt Made Out – Rajendra Sail in a public rally termed the High Court judgment acquitting accused in Niyogi murder case as “rubbish,” alleged bias, corruption and lack of honesty of judges, and questioned assignment of cases to retiring judges – Held: Statemen...
Criminal Law – Sentencing – Sections 307, 333 IPC – Undue Leniency by High Court – Order reducing sentence to period undergone set aside – Trial court convicted one accused under Sections 307 & 330 IPC and the other under Sections 307/34 & 333/34 IPC for assault on a constable with sharp weapon on a railway platform – High Court reduced sentence to about...
Murder – Sections 302 & 34 IPC – Eyewitness testimony and medical corroboration – Conviction Altered to 302/34 – Prosecution case supported by consistent eyewitnesses (PWs 2 & 3) and postmortem showing multiple incised wounds consistent with kirpan blows – Defence plea of false implication rejected in view of admitted presence and superficial nature of accused...
Criminal Law – Death Penalty – Rarest of Rare – Commutation – Bachan Singh Doctrine Reaffirmed – Appellant convicted of kidnapping and dismembering a friend’s body after murder for ransom – Sessions and High Courts imposed death penalty considering brutality and role of mastermind – Supreme Court holds that mitigating factors such as youth, no past c...