Criminal Law - Dismissal of Complaint – No Prima Facie Case – Allegations Patently Absurd and Inherently Improbable - The petitioner alleged an elaborate conspiracy involving multiple accused, claiming she was shot 25 times but survived due to homeopathic medicine – The Magistrate dismissed the complaint under Section 203 Cr.P.C., finding the allegations ex-facie improbable &ndas...
Criminal Law - False Affidavit – Whether Cognizance Under Section 340 CrPC Valid – Petitioner challenged cognizance taken by Magistrate under Sections 193/199/209 IPC—Held: Cognizance taken without a preliminary inquiry violates procedural safeguards—Order set aside [Paras 10-13].
Jurisdiction – Whether Application Should Have Been Heard by Original Court – C...
NDPS Act – Bail under Section 37 – Procedural Lapses Considered – Applicants accused of dealing in commercial quantities of Codeine Phosphate and Nitrazepam—Prosecution relied on recovery of contraband and WhatsApp chats—Defense argued procedural violations, including absence of proper certification under Section 52A—Held: Strict compliance with statutory proced...
Criminal Law – Appeal Against Conviction - Forgery and Fabrication – Lack of Primary Evidence – Conviction Set Aside – The appellant was convicted on the basis of allegations that he prepared the postal cover in which a forged marksheet was transmitted – The trial court relied on the testimony of a handwriting expert (PW-18) to establish the appellant’s involvem...
Criminal Law - Murder – Common Object – Unlawful Assembly – Conviction Under Section 302 IPC Upheld – Accused persons armed with swords fatally assaulted the deceased following a land and water dispute – The trial court and High Court convicted the accused under Sections 148 and 302 read with Section 149 IPC – Held: The prosecution successfully established the p...
Criminal Law – Murder of Wife – Appeal against conviction - Dying Declaration – Reliability and Contradictions – Conviction Set Aside – The deceased initially stated to a doctor (PW-13) and police constable (PW-9) that she caught fire accidentally while cooking – Subsequently, in a statement recorded by the Judicial Magistrate (PW-12), she alleged that the appel...
Criminal Law – Appeal against Conviction - Abetment of Suicide – Essential Elements – Absence of Proximate Incitement – Conviction Set Aside – For an offence under Section 306 IPC, there must be clear evidence of instigation or active participation in the act of suicide – Mere allegations of harassment, without direct incitement, are insufficient to establish ab...
Criminal Law - Murder – Dying Declaration – Conviction Under Section 302 IPC Sustained – The deceased suffered a fatal gunshot wound and, before succumbing, named the accused as his assailants before PW-1 (his wife) and PW-2 (his brother) – Both witnesses provided consistent testimonies regarding the deceased’s statement – Held: The dying declaration was credibl...
Criminal Law - Preventive Detention – PITNDPS Act - Detenus Already in Judicial Custody – No Material to Show Likelihood of Bail – Detention Orders Quashed – The detenus were already in judicial custody at the time of passing the detention orders – The detaining authority failed to record any cogent material suggesting that there was a likelihood of them being release...
Bail - Dowry Death – Grant of Bail – Stringent Scrutiny Required – Bail of In-Laws Cancelled – The appellant, brother of the deceased, challenged the bail granted by the High Court to four accused persons (the deceased’s in-laws) – The deceased had allegedly been harassed for dowry, with demands escalating from a motorcycle to a car – The post-mortem repor...