Section 217 CrPC Not A Mere Formality; Trial Court Must Judicially Decide Plea To Recall Witnesses Upon Alteration Of Charges: Madras High Court First Appellate Court Must Address Suspicious Circumstances Surrounding Execution Of Will; Adverse Inference To Be Drawn If Propounder Fails To Testify: Himachal Pradesh High Court Passing Contrary Orders On Identical Land Acquisition Cases Violates Public Policy, Equal Treatment: Madhya Pradesh High Court Municipal Authorities Cannot Adjudicate Title Disputes While Granting Building Permissions: Telangana High Court Statutory Insurance Companies Can’t Be Treated As Illiterate Litigants; Procedural Red Tape No Ground To Condone Delay: Orissa High Court Section 22 Hindu Succession Act Applies To Agricultural Land; Right Of Pre-Emption Is An Incident Of Succession: Supreme Court Proceedings Under Senior Citizens Act Extinguish On Death Of Applicant, Civil Remedies Apply For Property Disputes: Punjab & Haryana High Court Being A Woman Not A Ground For Bail In Heinous Crimes Against Minors: Gujarat High Court Rejects Bail In Flesh Trade Case Woman Not Entitled To Maintenance Under Section 125 CrPC If First Marriage Subsists; Illegitimate Child Entitled: Allahabad High Court Contract Workers Performing Same Duties As Regular Staff Entitled To Minimum Regular Pay Scale Under CLRA Rules: Bombay High Court Power Of Review Is To Correct Mistakes, Not Substitute Views Or Act As 'Appeal In Disguise': Kerala High Court Futile Exercise Of Jurisdiction To Proceed With Contempt For Violating Ex-Parte Order Once It Is Vacated On Merits: Karnataka High Court Threat To Force Wife Into Prostitution Strikes At Core Of Human Dignity: Gujarat HC Denies Anticipatory Bail In Abetment To Suicide Case Injured Victim's Testimony Carries Built-In Guarantee Of Truthfulness, Requires No Corroboration For Conviction: Allahabad High Court Section 138 NI Act Offence Can Be Compounded At Revision Stage Under Section 147 Read With Section 320 CrPC: Punjab & Haryana High Court

"CRIMINAL LAW" Digest

Criminal Law - Defamation – Section 199 Cr.P.C. – No Bar to Magistrate's Direction under Section 155(2) – Petition Dismissed - Petitioner challenged the registration of NCR and filing of chargesheet under Section 500 IPC based on the ground that defamation offences under Chapter XXI IPC can only be prosecuted by private complaint under Section 199 Cr.P.C. – Held: Sectio...

Criminal Writ - Police Surveillance – History-Sheet – Single Case Registered in 2016 – History-Sheet Quashed – Petitioner had only one criminal case registered in 2016 under the Cow Slaughter Act – No further offence, complaint, or FIR registered – Despite this, history-sheet under Category 18-A was opened and representation for closure rejected – Held: No...

Criminal Trial – Communal clash – Right of private defence – Occurrence arose when group of deceased and others attacked appellant’s house following earlier quarrel – Deceased stabbed by appellant; co-accused sustained injuries from prosecution party – Trial Court convicted appellant under Section 302 IPC, upheld by High Court – Supreme Court held: Even ac...

Section 27 Evidence Act – Discovery of a fact – Pulukuri Kottaya re-affirmed – Division Bench of Bombay High Court’s departure disapproved – “Fact discovered” not synonymous with “object recovered” – What is discovered is the fact that the object was concealed at a place to the accused’s knowledge – Recovery is merely a step t...

Murder – Conviction – Evidence – Medical evidence vs. ocular testimony – Where medical evidence runs counter to the eye-witness version, the prosecution case becomes doubtful – Ocular testimony of related/ interested witnesses requires strict scrutiny, particularly when corroboration from medical/ scientific evidence is absent – Held: Prosecution failed to estab...

Criminal Law - Quashing of Proceedings – Section 482 CrPC – Scope – Power is exceptional and to be exercised sparingly – High Court erred in quashing charge-sheet by assessing sufficiency of evidence as if conducting a trial – At stage of cognizance/framing of charge, court not to weigh evidence but only see whether allegations prima facie disclose commission of offen...

Murder and Abduction – Sections 302, 364, 149 IPC – Conviction set aside – Prosecution alleged that appellants along with others abducted Sukhchain Singh and murdered him – Evidence of PW-7 regarding disposal of body found unreliable as identification from long distance at early hours improbable and testimony full of contradictions – High Court itself disbelieved evid...

Juvenile Justice – Determination of juvenility - Murder case – Accused Pranjal Tiwari apprehended on 27.2.1997 for offence under Section 302/34 IPC – Claimed juvenility as date of birth 30.9.1981 – Trial court and Sessions Judge rejected claim citing doubts in documents and variation in ossification test – High Court in revision accepted documentary evidence and held ...

Dowry Death – Conviction based on sole testimony – Deceased, married for 1½ years, died by consuming poison allegedly due to dowry harassment – Trial court convicted respondents under Sections 304B and 498A IPC relying solely on testimony of father (PW4) – High Court disbelieved PW4, noting contradictions and lack of support from other relatives (PW6, PW7) who denied...

Murder – Sudden Quarrel – Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC – Applicability – The incident arose out of a sudden quarrel without prior enmity – Both the trial court and High Court found that the occurrence was without premeditation and fell within Exception 4 to Section 300 – Conviction altered from Section 302 to Section 304 Part I IPC – Sentence reduced to ...