Gratuity for Teachers – Constitutional Validity – The appeal addresses the constitutional validity of amendments extending gratuity benefits to teachers with retrospective effect. The Supreme Court upheld the amendments, emphasizing their purpose to rectify the omission of teachers from gratuity benefits and to ensure equitable treatment [Paras 1-22].
Retrospective Legisla...
Iron Ore Mining – Ceiling Limit Relaxation – Appeal to lift/relax the ceiling limit on iron ore production in the districts of Bellary, Chitradurga, and Tumkur. Supreme Court increases the ceiling limit from 28 MMT to 35 MMT for Bellary and from 7 MMT to 15 MMT collectively for Chitradurga and Tumkur, balancing economic development with environmental conservation [Paras 1-18].
 ...
Electoral Law – Promises and Freebies – Political parties challenged for promising and distributing free goods ('freebies') in election manifestos and speeches – Petitioners argued that such promises impact the economy and misuse taxpayer money to attract votes – Supreme Court emphasized the need for regulation but acknowledged the limited judicial intervention in f...
Environmental Law – Land Classification – State Government's refusal to change land classification from 'Johad' to 'Sawai Chak' challenged – High Court directed State Government to process the land allotment – Supreme Court upheld the decision, noting no environmental or catchment area concerns and compliance with necessary clearances [Paras 1-19].
&n...
Land Acquisition – Enhanced Compensation – Appeals filed by landowners challenging the High Court’s award of Rs. 780,000/- per acre – High Court had relied on previous decisions in Kapoor Singh and Surjit Singh cases – Supreme Court enhanced compensation further by Rs. 100,000/- per acre in cases relying on Kapoor Singh and Rs. 200,000/- per acre in cases relying on S...
Service Law – Recovery of Excess Payment – Medical officers received benefits under a 2009 circular later withdrawn in 2012 – No misrepresentation by employees, benefits paid due to department's mistake – Supreme Court held recovery of excess payments with interest unjustified given the department's error – Partial relief granted to appellants, stopping recove...
Administrative Law – Enhancement of Punishment – Letters Patent Appeal against Single Judge’s Order – Respondent’s three annual increments were stopped and subsequently, he was dismissed from service by the DIGP, CRPF. Appeal and revision were dismissed. Single Judge set aside the punishment orders due to lack of detailed consideration of the inquiry report and non-sp...
Municipal Law – Building Safety and Demolition – Building classified as C-1 (most dangerous) after structural audit – Demolition and eviction notices issued – High Court upheld notices, finding building unsafe – Supreme Court affirmed, citing compliance with legal procedures and protection of appellants' rights in redevelopment agreement [Paras 1-25].
...
Service Law – Cancellation of Appointments – Appellants qualified 6th Combined Civil Services Examination 2016, completed probation, and were appointed – High Court annulled appointments due to errors in qualifying marks and merit list preparation – Supreme Court found ambiguity in advertisement and upheld Commission's merit list preparation method – Appointments ...
Specific Relief – Specific Performance – Plaintiff breached essential contract conditions – Suit barred by delay and laches – Plaintiff delayed filing the suit by nearly five years – Supreme Court held plaintiff not entitled to specific performance due to their conduct – Relief under Section 12 not granted as delay and laches barred the claim [Paras 1-79].
&n...