Education Law – Admission and Eligibility – Fault of School – Petitioner took Class XII examination but was declared ineligible due to his Class X certificate being from a non-recognized school – Court held it was the responsibility of the admitting school to verify documents before granting admission to Class XI – Fault lies with the school, not the student – W...
Service Law – Selection Criteria – Elementary Trained Teachers (ETT) – Challenge to the selection criteria for ETT posts, which awarded additional marks for higher qualifications – Petitioners argued this was contrary to the Service Rules which mandate selection based solely on written test scores – Court held that the criteria violated Rule 6(4) of the 2018 Service R...
Habeas Corpus – Child Custody – Legal and Proper Detention – Petition for habeas corpus seeking release of minor son aged 14 years – Child living with grandfather and uncle since birth – Court held writ of habeas corpus maintainable only if custody is illegal or improper – Direct interaction with the child showed he was happy living with his grandfather and did ...
Constitutional Law – Habeas Corpus – Child Custody – Petition under Article 226 for habeas corpus seeking custody of minor child – Petition resisted due to the petitioner’s treatment for personality disorder and availability of alternative remedy under the Guardians and Wards Act – Court held that while habeas corpus is maintainable for child custody, the detail...
Stamp Duty – Assessment and Recovery – Jurisdiction and Limitation – Petitioner filed writ petitions against the State for initiating recovery of deficient stamp duty on assignment deeds registered in 2016. Revenue authorities claimed the deeds were conveyance deeds and insufficiently stamped. Petitioner contended that action was barred by limitation under Section 47-A of the Ind...
Land Acquisition – Assessment of Market Value – Challenge to market value assessment for different parcels of land in the same village acquired at different times – Previous Supreme Court assessments not automatically applicable – Market value to be determined based on the date of the Section 4 notification and contemporaneous sale exemplars – Comparable sale deeds of...
Professional Misconduct – Advocates Act – Writ Petition allowed – The Court directed the Bar Council of India and the Bar Council of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry to initiate appropriate disciplinary actions against the 5th respondent under the Advocates Act, 1961, for creating forged rental agreements to illegally occupy the petitioner’s property – Emphasized the need fo...
Ex Gratia Compensation – Interest on Delayed Payment – Appellant, a victim of the 1984 Anti-Sikh Riots, received ex gratia compensation after multiple litigations spanning decades – Appellant sought interest on the delayed payment of Rs. 1,00,000/- – High Court held that although ex gratia compensation traditionally does not attract interest, Constitutional Courts have the ...
Contract Law – Specific Performance of Agreement of Sale – Appeal against trial court’s decree for specific performance – Dispute regarding nature of the agreement (sale vs. mortgage) – Defendant’s claim of mortgage arrangement rejected due to lack of evidence – Plaintiff's readiness and willingness to perform contractual obligations established &ndash...
Land Acquisition – Market Value Assessment – Uniformity – Appellant challenged the assessment of market value for a narrow strip of land acquired for a road – Reference Court’s reliance on sale exemplars and judicial determinations questioned – High Court held that sale exemplars are more reliable than judicial determinations, which can vary based on evidence &n...