Trial Court Cannot Issue Summoning Order In Medical Negligence Case Without Waiting For Expert Report It Previously Directed: Punjab & Haryana HC

22 November 2026 4:02 PM

By: sayum


"In my opinion…. procedure adopted by the learned trial Court is in violation of its own direction, and therefore, perverse and contrary to the settled norms of judicial discipline," Punjab and Haryana High Court, in a significant ruling, held that a trial court cannot proceed to summon an accused medical professional while ignoring its own previous mandate to seek an expert opinion from a specialized medical institution.

A bench of Justice Surya Partap Singh observed that issuing a summoning order in a medical negligence case without waiting for a directed expert report is "perverse" and violates the established norms of judicial discipline.

The Court emphasized that in cases involving complex medical allegations, the judicial system must rely on expert bodies to determine if "culpable negligence" exists. The bench noted that when a court itself decides that a second opinion is necessary in the interest of justice, it cannot subsequently bypass that requirement to pass a coercive order against a doctor.

The matter originated from a criminal complaint filed by Sourabh Chhabra against Dr. Rohit Lalit (the petitioner) following the death of his 22-year-old sister, Simran Chhabra, on January 21, 2023. It was alleged that the deceased suffered complications and died after being administered a 'Dynapar 75' injection at the petitioner’s 'Jagdamba Hospital' for common ailments like fever and cough.

The respondent alleged gross medical negligence and moved the trial court after a District Medical Negligence Board in Gurugram gave a "clean chit" to the doctor. While the trial court initially refused to direct the registration of an FIR under Section 156(3) CrPC, it later ordered that a second expert opinion be sought from the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, before proceeding further.

The primary question before the High Court was whether the trial court committed a jurisdictional error by issuing a summoning order under Section 304-A IPC without waiting for the expert report from PGIMER Chandigarh, which the trial court itself had directed. The Court also considered whether such a procedure adhered to the settled principles of law governing the prosecution of medical professionals.

Expert Opinion Essential for Judicial Determination of Medical Negligence

The Court began by noting that the best body to assist the judicial system in determining medical negligence is a body of experts in the field. In the present case, a board of six doctors constituted by the Chief Medical Officer, Gurugram, had already rendered a professional opinion stating that Dr. Rohit Lalit could not be held negligent based on the facts and circumstances.

Trial Court Violated Its Own Procedural Directions

Justice Singh highlighted a significant procedural lapse where the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Gurugram, had specifically noted on September 28, 2023, that "the interest of justice demands the second opinion be sought from Director PGI Chandigarh." However, despite several adjournments to await this report, the trial court proceeded to hear arguments and issued the summoning order on September 4, 2024, in the absence of the report.

Summoning Without Awaiting Ordered Report Deemed Perverse

The Court found that the chronology of events made it abundantly clear that the trial court ignored its own direction. The High Court observed that if there was any difficulty in procuring the report from PGIMER, the trial court should have recalled its earlier order with a reasoned justification rather than acting in a "hasty manner."

"In my opinion, the above-mentioned procedure adopted by the learned trial Court is in violation of its own direction, and therefore, perverse and contrary to the settled norms of judicial discipline."

Importance of Adhering to Settled Norms in Doctor Prosecutions

The Court underscored that summoning in a complaint regarding medical negligence should generally not be ordered without an expert report. By bypassing the very report it had commissioned to ensure a fair conclusion, the trial court committed a "patent error" that undermined the reliability of its findings.

Second Expert Opinion Still Pending From PGIMER Chandigarh

The High Court noted that the trial court's decision to proceed without the PGIMER report was a deviation from the necessity of arriving at a proper conclusion. The bench reiterated that judicial discipline requires courts to follow their own directions unless they are formally set aside or modified through a transparent legal process.

"Taking into consideration the above-mentioned facts and circumstances of the present case, in my considered opinion, the learned trial Court while passing the impugned order has committed an error by ignoring its own order which otherwise was going to help the learned trial Court to arrive at a proper conclusion."

Reliance on Precedents Regarding Medical Negligence

The petitioner had placed heavy reliance on the Supreme Court’s landmark judgment in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, which established rigorous standards for prosecuting doctors to prevent unnecessary harassment. The High Court’s decision aligns with these principles, ensuring that a doctor is not forced to face a criminal trial without a corroborated expert finding of negligence.

The High Court allowed the petition and quashed the summoning order dated September 4, 2024, passed by the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Gurugram. The Court directed the trial court to procure the report from PGIMER Chandigarh as mandated earlier, appreciate it alongside other material on record, and then pass a fresh order in accordance with the law.

Date of Decision: June 05, 2026

Latest Legal News