-
by kapil
18 November 2026 8:08 PM
NEW DELHI — Holding that the constitutional guarantee of parity under Article 14 applies with full vigour to the exercise of judicial discretion under Section 389(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), the Supreme Court on November 17, 2026, ruled that an appellate or revisional court cannot selectively deny a stay of conviction to co-convicts who stand on an identical evidentiary and conspiratorial footing. A Bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu held that while stay of conviction remains an exceptional remedy, treating co-convicts differently without articulating an intelligible differentia constitutes arbitrary exercise of jurisdiction.
"It is axiomatic that same footing ought to yield same treatment, unless a stated reason justifies the departure. Without that reason, the dichotomy is not judicial discretion, but arbitrariness."
The criminal proceedings originated from an FIR registered in 2019 at Rampur alleging a criminal conspiracy under Sections 120-B, 420, 467, 468, and 471 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) involving the fraudulent procurement and use of two conflicting birth certificates for Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan. The trial court convicted Samajwadi Party leader Mohammad Azam Khan, his wife Dr. Tazeen Fatma, and their son Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan, awarding them sentences of up to seven years. In revision, the Allahabad High Court suspended the sentences of all three, but stayed the conviction solely in respect of Azam Khan while declining parity to his wife and son, prompting cross-appeals before the apex court.
Whether the High Court was justified in adopting divergent standards under Section 389(1) read with Sections 397 and 401 CrPC by granting a stay of conviction to one co-convict while declining identical relief to co-convicts facing the self-same conspiracy charge on identical evidence?
Whether an unreasoned departure from parity in granting interim relief under Section 389(1) CrPC violates the rule of law and the constitutional mandate of Article 14?
Appellate Courts Must Maintain Logical Consistency Among Co-Convicts on Identical Footing
Elucidating the statutory mechanics of Section 389(1) CrPC, the Bench drew a firm line of demarcation between the suspension of substantive sentences and the suspension of a conviction. The Court emphasized that while suspension of sentence merely defers the execution of penal sanctions during appellate or revisional pendency, staying a conviction halts the legal disability flowing from a judicial finding of guilt and demands compelling judicial justification.
"By settled jurisprudence, stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy requiring distinct, compelling judicial justification. Nonetheless, when evaluating a prayer for a stay of conviction, the court is duty-bound to maintain logical consistency among co-convicts who stand on identical evidentiary footing."
Addressing the State's challenge against the stay granted to Azam Khan, the Bench rejected the contention that the High Court had acted ex mero motu beyond the revision petition's prayer. The Court observed from the records that separate interlocutory applications seeking a stay of conviction were duly preferred by all convicts alongside their applications for suspension of sentence. The Court also held that the grounds weighed by the High Court, including custody period, advanced age, and absence of manual forgery, justified the exercise of discretion qua Azam Khan.
Unreasoned Departure From Parity In Granting Stay Of Conviction Amounts To Arbitrariness
Scrutinizing the High Court's refusal to extend identical interim relief to Dr. Tazeen Fatma and Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan, the Bench noted a stark and unsustainable legal dichotomy. The Court observed that the High Court failed to articulate any coherent legal basis for drawing a distinction between the co-convicts when all three were convicted under the unified umbrella of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC.
"Where several convicts standing on the same footing seek stay/suspension of conviction, it is legitimate for them to expect similar treatment by the court. Their treatment should not be affected by any legal dichotomy. Parity being a facet of Article 14 of the Constitution, equals ought to be treated equally unless, of course, an intelligible differentia having a rational nexus with the object of the order distinguishes one from the others."
The Bench underscored that although differential treatment is not per se impermissible, an unreasoned distinction cannot withstand judicial scrutiny. Where an appellate court departs from parity, the distinguishing features on record must be explicitly identified and recorded in the judicial order, failing which the decision lapses from lawful discretion into arbitrariness.
Conviction Causes Irreversible Damage To Dignity And Reputation Under Article 21
The Supreme Court highlighted that a criminal conviction inflicts immediate, profound trauma upon an individual's fundamental right to live with personal dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution. The Bench remarked that if a conviction is ultimately overturned on merits, the years endured under the crushing weight of societal disgrace and moral opprobrium cannot be retroactively repaired or monetarily compensated.
Referring to the majority opinion in Afjal Ansari v. State of U.P. (2024) 2 SCC 187, the Court reaffirmed that Section 389(1) CrPC cannot be interpreted in an overly restrictive manner where allowing a conviction to operate would cause irreversible damage. The Court reiterated that judicial discretion must balance the grave consequences visited upon a convict against the legal sanctity normally attached to a trial court's finding of guilt.
Stays Anchored Solely On Political Calendars And Electoral Ambitions Disavowed
While upholding the protective umbrella of Section 389(1) CrPC, the Bench introduced a vital caveat to govern future applications. The Court categorically disavowed any attempts by litigants to secure a stay of conviction predicated solely on political exigencies, electoral calendars, or ambitions to contest upcoming elections.
"We unequivocally disavow and reject any plea that seeks a stay of conviction anchored purely on political expediency, electoral ambitions, or the exigencies of upcoming election campaigns. Courts of law cannot permit statutory powers to be leveraged to suit political calendars or electoral ambitions."
Applying these calibrated principles, the Court held that the prosecution's entire case rested upon a single narrative of conspiracy concerning two birth certificates, with no distinct overt acts of physical forgery attributed to Abdullah Azam Khan or Dr. Tazeen Fatma beyond their joint status as co-conspirators. Consequently, denying them a stay of conviction while granting it to the patriarch amounted to a patent error of jurisdiction and arbitrary differentiation.
The Supreme Court dismissed the criminal appeals filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh against the stay of conviction granted to Mohammad Azam Khan. The Court allowed the appeals preferred by Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr. Tazeen Fatma, setting aside the High Court's order to the extent it denied them interim relief, and directed that their conviction dated October 18, 2023 shall remain stayed during the pendency of their criminal revisions before the High Court.
Date of Decision: November 17, 2026