"Karnataka High Court Upholds Homemaker's Right to Maintenance, Recognizes Childcare as Full-Time Responsibility"

In a landmark judgment, the Karnataka High Court has underscored the significance of a homemaker's role in raising children, affirming that "taking care of children is a full-time job." The court granted a monthly maintenance of ₹36,000 to a mother, who had quit her job to take care of her children.

Justice M. Nagaprasanna, presiding over the case, allowed the writ petition filed by Smt. Shylaja S. R and others against Sri Hareesha A, modifying a previous order by the II Additional Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Anekal. The earlier order had granted only half of the claimed maintenance amount.

In the judgment (Writ Petition No. 14094 of 2023), the court highlighted the mother's sacrifices, noting, "It is not in dispute that on the birth of the first child, the wife was asked to leave the job of a Teacher to take care of the child." The court emphasized the importance of a mother's role, saying, "The wife, as a homemaker and mother, works indefatigably round the clock."

The case revolved around the claim of interim maintenance by the petitioner, who had sought financial support for herself and her two children following the deterioration of her marriage. Her husband, a manager in Canara Bank with a salary close to ₹90,000, opposed the claim, suggesting that his wife, being qualified, should work and earn rather than depend on maintenance.

Rejecting this contention, the court observed, "The respondent being the husband, cannot be seen to contend that the wife is lazing around and not earning money to take care of the children." Justice Nagaprasanna cited various precedents, including the Apex Court's judgments, to emphasize that maintenance must enable the wife and children to continue living as they did before the marital discord.

This decision is seen as a significant acknowledgment of the non-economic contributions of homemakers in a marriage and their entitlement to financial support in cases of marital discord. The judgment serves as a reminder of the legal system's recognition of the intrinsic value of homemaking and childcare, roles often undervalued in monetary terms.

Date of Decision: 28-02-2024

SMT. SHYLAJA S. R AND OTHERS Vs. SRI HAREESHA A