Public Property Cannot Be Managed Privately for Decades — Fair Price Shops in Hospitals Must Be Allotted by Auction: Jammu & Kashmir High Court Registered Sale Deed Alone Does Not Dismantle Prior Security Interest: Gauhati High Court Rejects Buyer’s Writ Against SARFAESI Action, Cites Expanded Statutory Definition Old OBC Certificates Won’t Work — Supreme Court Says Cut-Off Date Is Final in Rajasthan Civil Judge Exams Power of Attorney Is Not a Licence to Defraud: Punjab & Haryana High Court Upholds Reversal of Sham Sale Deeds by GPA Holder Acting Against NRI Principal’s Interests Not Every Advocate Commissioner Appointment Is Evidence Gathering: Andhra Pradesh High Court Upholds Trial Court’s Discretion in Title Dispute No Invalidation Can Be Attached to One-Year LLM for Public Appointments: Madras High Court Orders Retrospective Appointment of Top-Ranked Candidate Section 63 of the Copyright Act | Publisher Can't Be Prosecuted for Author’s Plagiarism Without Proof of Knowledge: Kerala High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Mathrubhumi Directors Old Marital Disputes Aren’t Enough to Prove Suicide Was Instigated: Supreme Court Acquits Man Jailed for Wife’s Death by Fire Dependent Heir Can Remain in Tenanted Premises Only for Five Years from Tenant’s Death Under WB Tenancy Act: Supreme Court Exclusive Jurisdiction Clause in Employment Contract Binding Even in Termination Disputes: Supreme Court Entrustment Was to Run the Business, Not Occupy the Premises: Supreme Court Denies Deemed Tenancy Under Bombay Rent Act Preliminary Enquiry in Corruption Cases Is Desirable, Not Mandatory: Supreme Court Set Aside Quashing of FIR

By No Stretch of Imagination, It Can Be Held That the Labour Court at Chandigarh Has No Jurisdiction: High Court of Punjab and Haryana Holds Chandigarh Authorities Have Jurisdiction in Labour Dispute

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


In a significant judgment concerning the jurisdiction of labour disputes, the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh, led by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth, ruled that the Chandigarh authorities have jurisdiction over the labour dispute involving the termination of Upinder Kumar Singla by Groz-Beckert Asia Pvt. Limited.

The primary legal issue revolved around whether the Assistant Labour Commissioner-cum-Conciliation Officer, U.T. Chandigarh, had jurisdiction to entertain the dispute concerning the termination of the petitioner, who was working in Tirupur, Tamil Nadu, at the time of his termination, despite the decision being made at the company's head office in Chandigarh.

The petitioner, Upinder Kumar Singla, was terminated by Groz-Beckert Asia Pvt. Limited, with the termination order issued from the company's head office in Chandigarh but communicated in Tirupur. The petitioner contended that this termination was in violation of Section 25 F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. The Assistant Labour Commissioner initially took up the matter but later suo moto reviewed the decision on jurisdictional grounds, rejecting the demand notice.

The court meticulously analyzed various precedents, including "Nandram vs. M/s Garware Polyster Ltd.", "Bageshwar Maurya vs. Management Naveen Projects P. Ltd.", "Bikash Bhushan Ghosh & Ors vs. M/s Novartis India Limited and Anr", and "Bhola Nath Maurya and others vs. State of Punjab and others". The crux of these judgments underscored that the location of the decision-making process is pivotal in determining the jurisdiction.

Justice Vashisth observed, "By no stretch of imagination, it can be held that the Labour Court at Chandigarh has no jurisdiction." The judgment emphasized the role of the head office in Chandigarh in making the termination decision. The court thus set aside the order dated 25.09.2017 by the Assistant Labour Commissioner, holding that the Chandigarh authorities indeed have the jurisdiction to decide the dispute, directing the parties to proceed as per the law.

Date of Decision: 14.02.2024

Upinder Kumar Singla vs. Assistant Labour Commissioner-cum-Conciliation Officer, U.T., Chandigarh and Ors

 

Similar News