Service Law – Disciplinary Proceedings – Compulsory Retirement – Court examined the petitioner's challenge against the Tribunal's dismissal of his appeal regarding disciplinary actions including compulsory retirement, and later modification to withholding promotion for five years. The disciplinary actions stemmed from false declarations made by the petitioner concer...
Tender Disqualification – Grounds and Validity – Appellant disqualified from tender participation by the Board of Trustees of Jawaharlal Nehru Port Authority based on termination of a Concession Agreement by the Visakhapatnam Port Authority – High Court upheld disqualification – Appellant contended termination was retaliatory and pending arbitration – Supreme Court di...
Right to Education – Eligibility for Admission under EWS Category – Involves petition for admission of a child, Jiya, under the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category in a specific school for academic year 2023-24. High Court holds that right to education under Article 21A of the Constitution and Section 12 of the RTE Act entitles a child only to free and compulsory educa...
Advocates Act – Constitutional Validity of AOR Rules – Petitioner challenged Order IV Rule 1(b), Rule 5, and Rule 7(c) of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 – Contended these rules were discriminatory and violated Articles 14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution – Claimed the exclusive right given to AORs contravened Section 30 of the Advocates Act, 1961 [Paras 1-4].
Su...
Service Law- Letters Patent Appeal – Judgment dated 26.07.2023 – Writ petition challenging the disengagement order of Special Police Officer (SPO) – Enquiry conducted under Rule 359 of J&K Police Rules – No enquiry against the petitioner, violation of principles of natural justice – Petitioner engaged as SPO by respondents in 2013 – Disengaged on the g...
Permanent Commission – Armed Forces – Indian Navy – Women Officers – Short Service Commission – High Court's judgment challenged – AFT dismissed applications challenging denial of Permanent Commission – Principle issue whether AFT could adjudicate validity of selection proceedings when relevant material disclosed only to AFT in sealed cover – App...
Income Tax – Withholding Tax Certificate – Interpretation of Section 197 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 – The Delhi High Court examined whether the denial of a Nil withholding tax certificate to SFDC Ireland Limited by the Commissioner of Income Tax was justified. The petitioner, a resident of Ireland, argued that the payments received from SFDC India for the sale of standardized, n...
Constitutional Law – Transfer of Criminal Trial – Petitioners, being the daughter and wife of the deceased, sought transfer of trial and further investigation from Andhra Pradesh to Hyderabad or New Delhi – Supreme Court held that the petitioners’ apprehensions of a biased trial and investigation due to the influence of state authorities and threats to key witnesses were re...
Environmental Law – Felling of Trees – Aarey Forest – Permission sought for the felling of trees in Aarey Forest for the construction of a metro car depot – The Supreme Court permitted Mumbai Metro Rail Corporation Limited (MMRCL) to apply to the Tree Authority for felling 84 trees needed for the shunting segment of the car depot project – Court emphasized the need fo...
Service Law – Promotion and Service Matters – The petitioner sought promotion to the post of Chief Law Officer/Inspector General in BSF. The High Court examined the criteria for promotion, recruitment rules, petitioner’s medical category, and procedural delays in framing recruitment rules. [Para 2-4, 30-32]
Promotion Eligibility – held – eligibility for p...