Civil Law – Rejection of Plaint – Partition Suit – Cause of Action Disclosed – Appellant sought partition of ancestral and joint family properties – Trial court rejected plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC citing prior consent decree, limitation, and lack of co-ownership – Held: Plaint discloses cause of action – Questions of limitation, title, and effect o...
Civil Law – Additional Evidence – Order 41 Rule 27 CPC – Applications Must Be Decided With Appeal – Appellate Court dismissed application for additional evidence and another under Section 151 CPC during pendency of appeal – Held: As per binding precedent of Supreme Court (State of Rajasthan v. T. Sahani and K. Venkataramiah v. Seetharama Reddy), applications under Ord...
Motor Accident – Compensation – Fatal Accident – Pillion rider – Widow mother of deceased filed claim for Rs.15 lakhs – Tribunal awarded Rs.23,38,000/- with 7.5% interest – Tribunal wrongly deducted ½ of income instead of correct deduction method – High Court fixed monthly income at Rs.16,000/- based on bank statement – 40% added for future pr...
Property Law – Partition Suit – Effect of Previous Litigation – Interpretation of Decree – Appellants (Plaintiffs) sought partition of joint property claiming half share – Respondent (Defendant) contended that Appellants lost rights due to failure to pay Rs. 5,300/- as ordered in a previous Second Appeal (S.A. No. 641 of 1988) – First Appellate Court dismissed t...
Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act – Protected Tenancy – Statutory Purchase – Sections 32G & 32M – Effect of Mutation Entries – Exclusive Title – Civil Court Jurisdiction – Plaintiff (sister) filed suit for partition in 2002 claiming suit property as joint family property inherited from parents who died in 1949 and 1978 – Evidence showed t...
Family Law – Divorce – Cruelty – Decree of Divorce Granted – Appellant alleged repeated abusive conduct by wife, threats of suicide, denial of physical relationship, and desertion without cause – Family Court dismissed petition citing isolated nature of incidents and unclean hands due to dowry allegations – Held: Cumulative effect of wife’s behaviour inclu...
Electricity – Crop Damage – Strict Liability – Respondent’s wheat crop destroyed by fire due to electrical short-circuit from a Three Phase LT Line passing over his field – Writ Court directed compensation of ₹50,400 with 6% interest – Defence of natural calamity (wind storm) raised by State rejected – No proof of windstorm placed on record – High ...
Civil Law – Specific Performance – Agreement to Sell – Concurrent Findings – Appellant (Defendant) challenged the decree for specific performance of an agreement to sell land for ₹2,00,000/- – Plaintiff proved payment of ₹1,80,000/- earnest money and execution of agreement via marginal witness and scribe – Defendant admitted signatures but claimed they were ...
Municipal Law – Building Plan Sanction – Mixed-Use Regulations – Whether owner can be compelled to construct commercial ground floor in notified mixed-use streets – Held: No; mixed-use is only permissive, not mandatory – Authorities acted arbitrarily in denying sanction for purely residential construction – Deemed sanction upheld – Directions to approve fr...
Land Acquisition – Compensation by Agreement – Statutory Interest – Estoppel – Once compensation is voluntarily and conclusively fixed through an agreement under Section 7(2) of the Tamil Nadu Acquisition of Land for Industrial Purposes Act, 1997, the agreement becomes final and binding – Supreme Court held that such a concluded contract excludes the applicability of ...