Civil Law – Order 7 Rule 11 CPC – Scope – Rejection of Plaint – At the stage of deciding application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, only averments contained in the plaint are to be considered – Defence of the defendant or disputed questions of fact cannot be examined – Issues requiring evidence cannot be decided summarily [Paras 6–7].
Rent Contr...
Co-operative Law – Review Jurisdiction – Reference to Larger Bench – Review petition filed against judgment restoring money decree passed by Co-operative Court – Review based on subsequent coordinate Bench decision holding that Co-operative Courts lack jurisdiction for recovery above ₹10 lakh – Court held that issue raises substantial questions of law requiring auth...
Railways Act – Compensation for Untoward Incident – Death of Bona Fide Passenger – Presumption of Travel – Sections 123(c)(2) and 124A – Deceased died after accidentally falling from a moving train between Gopalapatnam and Duvvada – Inquest report, post-mortem report, police records all confirmed accidental fall – Held: Deceased was a bona fide passenger a...
Civil Law – Condonation of Delay – Delay of 853 days in filing restoration application under Order IX Rule 9 CPC – Applicant, daughter and power of attorney holder of deceased appellant, failed to respond to repeated notices for bringing LRs on record – Held: No “sufficient cause” shown for prolonged inaction – Medical records produced were sporadic and di...
Matrimonial Law - Hindu Marriage Act – Divorce on Ground of Cruelty – Mental Cruelty – Proof and Appreciation of Evidence – Husband sought divorce alleging abnormal and violent behaviour of wife due to alleged psychiatric illness suppressed prior to marriage – Allegations of schizophrenia and violent conduct during honeymoon and matrimonial life – Held: Husband ...
Civil Writ - Natural Resources – Tender-cum-Auction – Quarry Lease for Dunite – Cancellation of Tender – Successful bidders challenged cancellation of tender-cum-auction after being declared highest bidders and payment of EMD – Authorities cancelled tender on finding serious discrepancies in fixation of upset price leading to substantial loss to State revenue – ...
Income Tax – Bogus Purchases – Reopening of Assessment – Information from Sales Tax Department – AO reopened assessment based solely on list of alleged hawala dealers and added entire ₹2,05,74,750 as bogus purchases – Assessee produced purchase bills, VAT auditor’s certificate, ledger, and bank payment proof – CIT(A) restricted addition to 15% of reduced...
Real Estate – RERA Registration – Ongoing vs. Completed Project – Completion Certificate Issued Pre-RERA – Appellant’s project had received a valid completion certificate on 17 March 2015 – Tribunal wrongly held project as ongoing due to absence of fire safety certificate – Held: Under Regulation 67 of BDA Regulations, fire NOC suffices at completion stage...
Civil Law – Amendment of Pleadings – Order 6 Rule 17 CPC – Suit filed in 1995 based on major settlement RoR – Amendment sought in 2025 to introduce consolidation plot number for plaintiffs’ land alone – High Court held that such amendment at argument stage without including defendants’ corresponding plot from consolidation records would cause prejudice &nd...
Motor Vehicles Act – Injury Compensation – Enhancement – Permanent Partial Disability – Reassessment of Income – Application of Multiplier Method – Claimant aged 23 years, final year engineering student, sustained fracture of left scapula with brachial plexus injury resulting in 25% permanent partial disability – Tribunal awarded compensation based on mini...