Civil Law - Contract Interpretation – Success-Based Fee – Bank’s Discretion to Choose Fee Option Upheld – The dispute arose over whether the plaintiff was entitled to a success-based fee at 0.50% (Option ‘a’) or 0.0749% (Option ‘b’) for financial advisory services in the sale of NPAs – The plaintiff claimed the bank was obligated to pay at the ...
Civil Writ - Public Employment – Prescribed Qualification vs. Equivalent Qualification – KPSC’s Inconsistent Approach Struck Down – The petitioners contended that their qualifications, recognized by government institutions, were equivalent to the prescribed qualification in the recruitment notification – The Court found that the KPSC had arbitrarily excluded them desp...
Civil Procedure – Summary Judgment – Rejection of Application – Order XIII-A CPC – Requirement of No Real Prospect of Defense – Delhi High Court judgments relied upon – Summary judgment can be granted where there is no real prospect of success or defense – Court must ensure just disposal without unnecessary trial – Court held that since the issue of ...
Civil Law – Execution of Decree – Delay in Execution – Specific Performance – Tamil Nadu Cultivating Tenants’ Protection Act, 1955 – Appellants sought execution of decree for specific performance and possession of the suit property – Respondents 1 and 2 obstructed execution, claiming to be cultivating tenants – Executing Court and High Court allowed ...
Judicial Review – Scope in Academic Matters – Examination Answer Keys – Limited Interference – The Appellants challenged the final answer key issued by the Haryana Public Service Commission (HPSC) for the PGT (Chemistry) screening test, contending errors in evaluation – The High Court held that judicial intervention in academic matters is permissible only in cases of ...
Family Law – Divorce Petition – Territorial Jurisdiction – Section 19 of the Hindu Marriage Act – The wife objected to the jurisdiction of the Family Court, Cuttack, stating that the couple last resided together in June 2017, whereas the husband filed for divorce in February 2019 when he was no longer residing in Cuttack – Held: The plea of lack of jurisdiction must b...
Civil Law - Eviction – Default in Payment of Rent – Section 12(1)(a) of the M.P. Accommodation Control Act, 1961 – Eviction Decreed – The plaintiffs/landlords filed a suit for eviction on the ground of non-payment of rent, alleging that the tenant was in arrears since 01.09.1982 – The tenant disputed the rate of rent and claimed an agreement for adjustment of house ta...
Civil – Writ - Religious Institutions – Police Interference – Mandamus Issued – Departmental Inquiry Ordered – Police Directed Not to Interfere in Religious Disputes – The Uttaradi Mutt filed a writ petition alleging that the police coerced them to hand over the keys of Sri Narahariteertha Swamy Brundavana to Sri Raghavendra Swamy Mutt – The petitioner cit...
Taxation Law - Income Tax – Refund – Interest on Delayed Payment – Entitlement of Assessee – Refund Granted with Interest – The petitioner applied under the Direct Tax Vivad Se Vishwas Act, 2020, and was entitled to a refund of Rs.2,20,41,042/- as per the order dated 12/05/2022 – Despite multiple representations, the refund was delayed due to alleged validation ...
Arbitration and Conciliation – Maintainability of Arbitration Petition – Settlement Through Conciliation – The Petitioner sought appointment of an Arbitral Tribunal to adjudicate disputes arising from an EPC Agreement with the Respondent – Respondent contended that disputes had already been settled through conciliation meetings held under Clause 26.2 of the Agreement &ndash...