Wife's Insistence on Separating Husband from Parents Without Reason is Cruelty-Calcutta HC

The Calcutta High Court has ruled that it is common for Indian sons to reside with their parents even after marriage, and that a wife must have a justifiable reason for separating her husband from his parents. Justices Soumen Sen and Uday Kumar made the decision while hearing a plea from a woman challenging a court order that granted her husband a divorce on grounds of cruelty.

The court noted that there were unjustifiable reasons for the wife's attempt to separate her husband from his family. It cited instances of ego clashes over petty domestic issues and challenges related to fulfilling financial requirements.

The husband had moved out of his parents' house and into a rented one for the sake of his matrimonial peace, and the court noted that the wife's persistent efforts to separate him from his family would be torturous for him.

The bench further stated that a son's duty towards his parents is sacred and that it is customary for Indian families to live together. The court emphasized that a wife cannot demand that her husband break away from his parents without a valid reason.

In dismissing the wife's plea, the court upheld the importance of family ties and recognized the cultural significance of multi-generational living in India.

The ruling reinforces the notion that marriage does not mean severing ties with one's parents and upholds the traditional values of Indian families.

JHARNA MANDAL Vs. PRASHANT KUMAR MANDAL