Allahabad High Court Sets Aside Summoning Order in Matrimonial Dispute, Emphasizes Thoughtful Consideration in Such Cases

In a significant ruling that underscores the careful examination required in cases of matrimonial disputes, the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad set aside a summoning order in a case involving allegations of assault, abuse, and theft of valuables. The court’s decision was based on the principle of “application of mind” in issuing summoning orders, highlighting the need for thorough consideration before summoning the accused parties.

The judgment was delivered by Justice Ram Manohar Narayan Mishra on August 11, 2023, following a review of the impugned order and a fresh evaluation of the case. The case had been brought before the court through a petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

In its observations, the court emphasized that summoning an accused in a criminal case is a serious matter and not to be taken lightly. The court cited the precedent set in the case of Mehmood UI Rehman Vs. Khazir Mohammad Tunda and others (2015) 12 SCC 420, stating that the magistrate must apply their mind to the facts and law governing the case before issuing process against the accused. The court further noted that matters involving matrimonial disputes require thoughtful consideration, especially when the parties involved are spouses and in-laws.

Justice Mishra iterated, “The magistrate is not required to delve upon meticulous examination of evidence recorded... He has to examine the nature of allegations made in the complaint and the evidence both oral and documentary in support thereof and would that be sufficient for the complainant to succeed in bringing charge home to the accused.”

Considering the ongoing matrimonial dispute between the parties and the existence of multiple complaints and cases, the court highlighted the need for a balanced approach in cases involving such sensitive matters.

As a result, the High Court set aside the impugned orders and remanded the matter to the learned magistrate for a fresh consideration. The court directed that the complainant be given an opportunity to be heard, and a reasoned and comprehensive order be passed in accordance with the court’s observations.

Date of Decision: 11^th August 2023

Smriti Singh And 5 Others vs State of U.P. and Another