Civil Law - Central Excise Valuation - Central Excise Act 1944 - Section 11A and Section 35L - Rule 8 of the Central Excise Valuation Rules 2000 - Appellants engaged in body building of motor vehicles as job workers utilizing chassis supplied by manufacturers - Manufacturers paid excise duty on chassis under Rule 8 at 110 percent of the cost of manufacture - Appellants computed excise duty on comp...
Writ Law - Alternative Remedy - Constitution of India 1950 - Article 226 - Maintainability of Writ Petition - Petitioner challenged an Order-In-Original imposing tax and penalty under CGST Act and Rules, alleging violation of natural justice on ground of non-supply of seized documents during adjudication proceedings - Petitioner contended documents including books of accounts and electronic device...
Civil Law - Service Tax - Finance Act 1994 - Sections 65(105)(zzd), 66, 67, 65(105)(zzzza) - Indivisible Turnkey Contracts - Commissioning or Installation Service - Artificial Vivisection - Constitutional Limitations - Respondent-assessee engaged in supplying, installing and commissioning ATMs under indivisible turnkey contracts for a composite consideration - Revenue sought to levy service tax on...
Civil Law - Central Excise - Central Excise Act 1944 - Section 2(f) - Central Excise Tariff Act 1985 - Note 6 to Section XVI - Whether kitting and grouping of imported photocopier modules in CKD or SKD condition amounts to manufacture - Assessee imported parts and modules under Tariff Heading 8471 paying customs duty and countervailing duty as complete machines - Assessee performed kitting and gro...
Civil Law - Income Tax - Income Tax Act 1961 - Sections 44B and 195 - Presumptive Taxation - Applicability to Cruise Services - Non-resident entity (Superstar Libra Ltd. - SLL) operated cruise services in India through an agent (Assessee) - Revenue collected from cruise packages and shore excursions - Assessee claimed SLL's income to be assessed under Section 44B at 7.5% of gross receipts for ...
Tax Law - Retrospective Amendment - Karnataka Sales Tax Act 1957 - Section 8 - Fifth Schedule - Entry 51 - Appellants engaged in trading imported sugar - Prior to 2001 sugar was exempted under the Fifth Schedule without origin-based restrictions - Original assessments granted exemption - Karnataka Act No. 5 of 2001 retrospectively inserted the words produced or manufactured in India to restrict ex...
Writ Law - Constitutional Validity - Mines and Minerals Development and Regulation Act 1957 - Section 9 - Inclusion of royalty in sale value - Petitioners challenged Explanations to Rule 38 of 2016 Rules and Rule 45 of 2017 Rules which included Royalty DMF and NMET in computation of Average Sale Price - Argued this created a cascading royalty on royalty effect violating Section 9 ad valorem princi...
Taxation Law - Service Tax - Finance Act 1994 - Sections 65 66 83 - Business Auxiliary Service - The central issue was whether BPCL and HPCL acted as agents providing Business Auxiliary Service to Mahanagar Gas Limited or if they were buyers of Compressed Natural Gas on a principal to principal basis - The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the service tax demand holding it was a Principal to Agent ...
Criminal Law - Appeal against acquittal - Code of Criminal Procedure 1973 - Section 378 - Gujarat Sales Tax Act 1969 - Sections 75 and 80 - Central Sales Tax Act 1956 - Section 9 - Respondents serving as Sales Tax Officers were accused of criminal misconduct by approving a refund claim at four percent without proper verification of C Forms submitted by a trader - Trial Court acquitted the accused ...
Criminal Law - Regular Bail - Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 - Section 483 - Central Goods and Services Tax Act 2017 - Sections 132 and 69 - Petitioner proprietor of M/s Maa Steel Ludhiana sought bail after being arrested for alleged tax evasion and illegal ITC claim of Rs. 9.66 Crores - Allegations involved creation of fake invoices and E-way bills for iron and steel goods without actual...