Maintenance – Assessment of Income – Section 125 CrPC – Income Assessed on Basis of Minimum Wages – Maintenance Awarded – The petitioner claimed that his income was incorrectly assessed as ₹16,000 per month by the Family Court, which relied on Delhi's minimum wage standards despite the petitioner being employed in Uttar Pradesh. Held: In matrimonial disputes, pa...
Family Law – Divorce by Mutual Consent (Mubara'at) – Appeal allowed – Appellant sought declaration of her divorce by mutual consent (Mubara'at) under Muslim Personal Law – The marriage was solemnized in 1984, with mutual separation occurring in 1990 – The couple mutually agreed to divorce in 1999 and executed a notarized “Talaqnama Tehreer” in 2000...
Transfer Petition – Inconvenience of Travel – The petitioner, a resident of Hyderabad, sought the transfer of divorce proceedings from Nirmal to Hyderabad, citing difficulty in traveling from Hyderabad to Nirmal with a minor child – The respondent contended that the petitioner resides in Nirmal and falsely claimed Hyderabad as her residence to file a dowry harassment case –...
Live-in Relationships – Protection of Life and Liberty – Petitioners in CRWP No. 4660 of 2021 and CRWP No. 149 of 2024, though already married to third parties, sought protection for their life and liberty while living in a live-in relationship – Held: Despite societal and moral objections, the right to live with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution must be protected, irr...
Ex Parte Order in Maintenance Case – Non-Appearance of Petitioner – Section 125 CrPC – The petitioner challenged the ex parte order passed by the Family Court, directing him to pay maintenance of Rs. 10,000 per month to his wife – Petitioner contended that no proper notice of hearing was served, and the Family Court failed to observe whether his absence was wilful – H...
Ancestral Property and Ownership Claims – Petitioners asserted that the property in dispute, allotted to their grandfather in 1974, was ancestral and a shared household – Contention rejected as petitioners never challenged the mutation of the property in the name of their father Jagdish Prasad in 1992-93 – Held: Petitioners’ claim of shared ownership barred by law of limita...
Jurisdiction – Guardianship of Minor – Section 9 of Guardians and Wards Act – The petitioner challenged the maintainability of the guardianship suit before the Ranchi Family Court, arguing that the minor ordinarily resides in Delhi – The trial court rejected the application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, stating that jurisdiction was a mixed question of law and fact to be deter...
Facts:
Aishwarya Atul Pusalkar, the appellant, sought to enforce her right to reside in her matrimonial home, which was comprised of two flats in a redeveloped building. The building's reconstruction was undertaken under the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Act, 1976, with provisions for rehabilitation of displaced occupants.
Issues:
Whether the appellant's cl...
Maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. – Enhancement of Maintenance – The petitioner, an elderly mother, sought enhancement of the maintenance amount awarded by the Family Court – She argued that the current maintenance of ₹2000/- was insufficient for her needs, including medical expenses – Held: The court found that the petitioner was receiving a family pension and intere...
Family Law – Appeal for Declaration of Matrimonial Status – Appeal under Section 19 of the Family Court Act 1984 – The appellant, Smt. Hasina Bano, filed an appeal against the dismissal of the suit by the Family Court, Jhansi, seeking a declaration of her matrimonial status as "divorced" by mutual consent (mubara’at) under Muslim Personal Law – The trial cou...