Factual and Procedural Background – Victim hit by vehicle; compensation awarded by Tribunal; Insurance company appeals the quantum, disputing calculations related to dependency and other allowances – Respondent No.6 held guilty of negligent driving; compensation awarded for various losses including consortium and affection - [Paras 1-3]
Insurance Appeal – Challenged ...
Right to Lead Evidence in Rebuttal – Article 227 Challenge Against Order – Permission to Lead Evidence in Rebuttal Denied by Trial Court – High Court Sets Aside Order – Right to Rebuttal Implicitly Reserved by Petitioner – Held, Right to Rebuttal Permissible Under Order XVIII Rule 3 CPC When Onus is on Respondents, High Court Allows Petitioner to Lead Rebuttal Evidenc...
University Employment Regularization – Challenge against High Court's dismissal of appeal concerning regularization of appellants' temporary academic positions after reorganization of university center - Appellants appointed through regular selection process as per UGC and university standards; court highlighted errors in High Court's application of precedents and statutory inter...
Service Law - Challenging Procedure in Departmental Enquiry – Interpretation and Application of Law – Petitioner, a workman, challenged the procedural validity of his termination based on a departmental enquiry by invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. The Labour Court-II upheld the procedure as valid, which was contested in this writ petition. T...
Jurisdictional Challenge and Applicability of Labour Laws – Petitioner contends that being governed by the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, they are exempt from other labour legislations as the Act provides a complete code; Assistant Labour Officer's jurisdiction challenged – High Court finds that the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act does not preclude the application of general ...
Repudiation of Insurance Claim – Analysis of Material Suppression – Appellant’s claim repudiated by respondent insurance company on the grounds of non-disclosure of pre-existing insurance policies held by the insured-deceased – NCDRC upheld repudiation – Supreme Court finds repudiation to be unjustified due to lack of adequate evidence supporting respondent’s cl...
Gift Deeds and Basic Amenities Requirement – Dispute over ownership and right to stay in flats gifted by father to son – The Maintenance Tribunal nullified gift deeds executed in favor of the petitioner son, based on allegations of non-provision of basic amenities by the son post-transfer – Analysis centers on whether gift deeds were subject to the conditions of providing basic a...
Easementary Rights – Dispute over 20ft. wide road in land Survey No.57 Hissa No.13A/1 owned by Ramani's, claimed by Gala's under easement – Gala's (appellants) claimed easementary rights over the road which is part of respondents' property – Suit filed for declaration of easementary rights and for permanent injunction – Original suit decreed but overturned b...
Challenge Against Auction Sale Notice – Borrower’s application in DRT under SARFAESI Act against auction notice by UCO Bank – Interim DRT order allowing auction with conditions – Conditions unmet by Borrower – Auction completed and sale confirmed in favor of appellant [Paras 3.3, 3.5, 3.6, 10].
Restoration of Securitization Application – Dismissal b...
Curative Petition – Invoked under Article 142 – Addressing miscarriage of justice in arbitral award interpretation – Overlooking of vital evidence and erroneous contractual interpretation leading to an undeserved financial burden on DMRC – Curative petition maintainable and allowed. [Paras 30-72]
Arbitral Award Review – Patently Illegal – Incorrect ...