Law of Limitation Must Be Applied Strictly; Mere Negligence or Inaction Cannot Justify Delay: Punjab & Haryana High Court Discharge from Service for Non-Disclosure of Criminal Case Held Arbitrary, Reinstatement Ordered: Calcutta High Court Maintenance for Children Restored from Date of Petition, Residence Order Limited to Pre-Divorce Period: Kerala High Court Shared Resources Must Be Preserved: P&H HC Validates Co-Owner's Right to Irrigation Access Position of Authority Misused by Lecturer to Exploit Student: Orissa High Court Rejects Bail to Lecturer in Sexual Assault Case Temporary Disconnection Of Water Supply Without Unlawful Or Dishonest Intent Does Not Constitute ‘Mischief’: Kerala High Court Quashed Criminal Proceedings Adult Sons' Student Loans Not a Valid Ground to Avoid Alimony: Calcutta High Court Ancestral Property Requires Proof of Unbroken Succession: Punjab & Haryana HC Rejects Coparcenary Claim Grant of Land for Public Purpose Does Not Divest Ownership Rights: Bombay High Court on Shri Ganpati Panchayat Sansthan's Reversionary Rights Punjab and Haryana High Court Rules Against Government Directive on Proving Experience of Deputy District Attorneys Orissa High Court Reduces Compensation in Motor Accident Case: Insurer’s Appeal Partly Allowed Service Law – Promotion Criteria Cannot Be Imposed Beyond Recruitment Rules: Supreme Court Access To Clean And Hygienic Toilets Is Not Just A Matter Of Convenience But A Fundamental Right Under Article 21: Supreme Court Promotions Under Merit-Cum-Seniority Quota Cannot Be Based Solely on Comparative Merit: Supreme Court Reliefs Must Be Both Available and Enforceable at the Time of Filing to Attract Order II Rule 2 Bar: Supreme Court Punjab & Haryana High Court Upholds Collector’s Appointment of Ex-Serviceman as Lambardar: Preference for Service to the State Valid Tax to Be Computed at 100% Under DTVSV Act, Rejects Inclusion of Belated Grounds in Disputed Tax: Bombay High Court Petitioner’s Father Did Not Fall Within Definition of Enemy – Kerala High Court Quashes Land Classification Under Enemy Property Act Calcutta High Court Upholds Cancellation of LPG Distributor LOI for Violating Guidelines Recording 'Reasons to Believe' is a Mandatory Safeguard, Not a Mere Formality Under PMLA: P&H High Court Illegality Is Incurable, Unauthorized Constructions Cannot Be Regularized: Bombay High Court Kerala High Court Quashes Tribunal’s Order Granting Retrospective UGC Benefits to Librarians Without Required Qualifications

Supreme Court Criticizes High Court’s Casual Approach, Grants Bail to 70-Year-Old Nearly Blind Convict

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


“High Court’s failure to consider age, health, and sentence served is troubling,” says Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has granted bail to Bherulal, a 70-year-old convict with significant visual impairment, after criticizing the High Court of Madhya Pradesh for its casual and mechanical rejection of his plea for suspension of sentence. The bench, consisting of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Ujjal Bhuyan, emphasized the need for courts to apply correct principles when considering the suspension of fixed-term sentences, especially in cases involving elderly and ailing individuals.

Bherulal was convicted by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh, for offenses under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 120-B, and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, and sentenced to four years of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 5,000. After serving two years of his sentence, Bherulal appealed to the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, seeking suspension of his sentence and bail pending appeal. Despite multiple applications, the High Court consistently rejected his pleas without substantial reasoning, leading to the filing of a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court was unequivocal in its criticism of the High Court’s handling of Bherulal’s applications. “Stereo type orders are passed by the High Courts without any application of mind,” the bench observed, highlighting the lack of detailed reasoning in the High Court’s decisions. The Supreme Court noted the High Court’s failure to consider Bherulal’s age, his significant visual impairment, and the fact that he had already served half of his sentence.

The Supreme Court reiterated the established legal principle that appellate courts should liberally consider suspension of sentences for fixed terms unless there are exceptional circumstances to deny such relief. “There is nothing observed by the High Court in its impugned order as to why the plea for suspension of sentence deserved to be declined,” the bench stated, emphasizing that no exceptional circumstances were noted to justify the High Court’s decision.

The Supreme Court took into account Bherulal’s advanced age and severe health condition, noting that he is “virtually blind” and has already served two years of his four-year sentence. The Court remarked that the High Court’s casual approach necessitated the intervention of the Supreme Court, which could have been avoided had the High Court applied the correct legal principles.

Justice Pardiwala remarked, “The High Court should have realized that the petitioner is seventy years of age and out of four years of maximum sentence imposed, has already undergone two years’ of sentence. The petitioner is virtually blind. There is nothing on record to indicate that his release on bail pending appeal would thwart the course of justice.”

The Supreme Court’s decision to grant bail to Bherulal underscores the judiciary’s responsibility to consider the unique circumstances of each case, particularly involving elderly and ailing convicts. By highlighting the High Court’s oversight and emphasizing the proper application of legal principles, this judgment reinforces the need for thoughtful and reasoned judicial decisions. The Supreme Court’s order not only provides immediate relief to Bherulal but also serves as a crucial reminder for lower courts to exercise their discretion judiciously and compassionately.

 

Date of Decision: July 03, 2024

Bherulal v. The State of Madhya Pradesh

Similar News