No Mandate in Recruitment Rules for Subject-Wise Specification in Home Science - Supreme Court Upholds KPSC Lecturer Notification

In a significant judgment, the Supreme Court of India has ruled in favor of the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC) regarding the recruitment of lecturers in Home Science. The Court found that there is no requirement in the recruitment rules for specifying subject specializations within the field of Home Science for lecturer positions.

The appeal was against the decision of the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal and the High Court, which had quashed a KPSC notification for recruiting 18 lecturers in Home Science, citing the lack of subject specialization details. The appellants argued that this requirement was not mandated by the governing recruitment rules.

Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, delivering the judgment, emphasized, "Service jurisprudence must begin and end with rules that govern the process." The Court scrutinized the Karnataka Education Department Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1964, and the Special Recruitment Rules, 1993. They noted that these rules only require a Master's Degree in Home Science, without a need for specialization, for teaching undergraduate students.

The Court pointed out the High Court's error in extending its review beyond the stipulated rules, stating, "If the High Court had confined itself to the basic features of judicial review, it would have avoided committing the error that it did."

The judgment also referenced an affidavit from the University Grants Commission (UGC), supporting the non-requirement of subject-wise classification for Home Science lecturer posts.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeals, setting aside the judgments of the High Court and the Tribunal. The recruitment process based on the KPSC notification was upheld.

Date of Decision: February 22, 2024

SMT. VIDYA K. & ORS. VERSUS STATE OF KARNATAKA & ORS.