Company Law – Criminal Complaint – Vicarious Liability Absent – Summons Quashed – Petitioners challenged prosecution under Section 147(2) of the Companies Act for failure to display company name and address as per statutory requirement – Held: Directors not holding office at the time of alleged default cannot be held liable – Complaint lacked specific averments ...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR – Commercial Dispute – FIR Quashed – Appellant, a Sri Lanka-based importer, was accused by an Indian seller of cheating and criminal breach of trust for non-payment of ₹34.71 lakhs for sarees exported through a third-party exporter (M/s Oswal Overseas) – Supreme Court held that the transaction was a commercial one with no direct entrus...
Criminal Procedure Code – Quashing of FIR – Exercise of Power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. – FIR challenged relating to contract between parties and alleged suppression of restrictive covenant – Held: Allegations, even taken at face value, disclose purely civil dispute regarding payment of money and not criminal offence – No dishonest intention at inception shown –...
Criminal Law - Section 319 CrPC – Scope and Threshold – Prima-facie Evidence – Invocation Justified – Appellant challenged High Court's quashing of Trial Court order summoning Respondent No. 2 based on direct eyewitness testimony during trial – Held: Once sworn evidence implicates an individual not initially arraigned, and such evidence is stronger than mere sus...
Discharge Application – Absence of Sanction – Cognizance Invalid – Prosecution Barred – Petitioner, a retired official, was prosecuted without obtaining sanction under Section 197 CrPC for IPC offences – Court held cognizance taken without required sanction is procedurally defective and unsustainable – Impugned order rejecting discharge application set aside [Pa...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR - Criminal Conspiracy and Forgery – Role of Professional Valuer – FIR Quashed – Petitioner, an empanelled bank valuer, was accused of preparing false valuation reports without physically inspecting properties – Court held petitioner relied on representations made by bank officer and submitted a valuation opinion, not a forged document &n...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR - Criminal Proceedings in Matrimonial Disputes – General Omnibus Allegations – Proceedings Quashed in Part – Supreme Court precedents reiterated that vague, sweeping allegations lacking specifics against distant relatives cannot sustain criminal charges – FIR and charge sheet quashed against Petitioner No.4 (a distant relative) for lack ...
Criminal Law - Discharge Petition – Absence of FIR Mention Not Ground to Discharge – Petition Dismissed – Petitioner sought discharge citing non-mention of name in FIR and acquittal of co-accused in original trial – Court held that FIR is not an encyclopedia and acquittal of co-accused irrelevant as evidence was not recorded in presence of present petitioner – Charge ...
Criminal Law – Quashing of Cognizance - Custodial Violence Allegation – Police Officers Summoned – Cognizance Quashed - Petitioners, senior police officers, challenged summoning order in a complaint case alleging police excess during a bandh protest in 2014 – Held: Proceedings initiated after an unexplained delay of 10 years, during Model Code of Conduct, are manifestly mal...
Criminal Law - Quashing of Criminal Proceedings – Section 9, 10, 11, 12 & 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 - Lack of Prima Facie Evidence – Case based on CDRs and Transcripts – Quashing Allowed - The petitioners challenged the FIR, charge sheet, and summoning order alleging conspiracy and illegal gratification to obtain a loan from Sy...