Criminal Law - Sentencing – Excessive Incarceration – Original Sentence Restored – Appeal Allowed - The appellant, originally sentenced to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment by the Special Court, had his sentence enhanced to life imprisonment by the High Court – Having already served eleven years and eight months in custody, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court&...
Criminal Law - Suspension of Sentence – Section 389 CrPC – Scope and Judicial Discipline – High Court Order Set Aside - The High Court suspended the sentence of the convict under POCSO on the ground of doubtful age of victim without conclusively reversing the trial court's finding – Held: Suspension of sentence under Section 389 requires judicial restraint and cannot pr...
Criminal Law – Quashing - Medical Negligence – Discharge Delays and Billing Discrepancy – No Offence Made Out - Petitioner, an advocate, alleged wrongful confinement and cheating by Max Hospital during cashless insurance surgery – Dispute arose over excess billing and delay in discharge – Court held that while harassment due to discharge process is real, it does not c...
Criminal Law - Dishonour of Cheque – Legal Presumption under NI Act – Conviction Upheld - Accused admitted issuance of cheque but claimed it was issued in connection with a proposed joint business – Trial Court and Appellate Court held that presumption under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act was not rebutted – Accused failed to lead any defence evidence despite ample oppor...
Criminal Law – Kidnapping and Murder - Appeal Against Conviction - Circumstantial Evidence – Chain Complete – Conviction Upheld – Minor boy kidnapped and strangled by appellant for ransom – Dead body recovered buried in yard at appellant’s instance – Cotton rope and blood-stained clothes recovered – Scientific and postmortem evidence confirmed cause ...
Criminal Procedure – Quashing FIR – Co-Accused’s Statement – Premature to Interfere – Applicant named in liquor seizure case solely based on co-accused’s statement – Held: Statement under Section 10 of Evidence Act relevant during investigation though inadmissible at trial – At FIR stage, admissibility not determinative – Court cannot scuttle i...
Criminal Law - Civil Dispute – Not Criminal – Petition for FIR Quashed – No Case for Cheating - Petitioner sought action against uncles who allegedly sold property in Solan despite prior relinquishment in family settlement – Court found the dispute to be civil in nature, not amounting to criminal fraud or misrepresentation – Held: No ingredients of Section 415 IPC mad...
Criminal Law – Rape - Acquittal Appeal – Scope of Appellate Interference in Acquittal – Appellate Court Reiterated Limited Scope to Interfere – The appellate court while re-appreciating the evidence must interfere only when the judgment is perverse or leads to miscarriage of justice – Court found that trial court's judgment was not perverse and based on sound appr...
Regular Bail – Murder - Delay in Trial – Prolonged Incarceration – Bail Granted – Petitioner in custody for over 6 years with only 2 out of 17 witnesses examined since framing of charges in 2021 – Trial likely to take a long time – Held: Continued detention without substantial trial progress violates Article 21 rights – Bail granted subject to conditions [...
Criminal Law – Quashing - Section 138 and 141, Negotiable Instruments Act - Vicarious Liability – Director Not in Management – Complaint Quashed - Petitioner challenged proceedings under Section 138 NI Act, asserting he was neither a Director nor signatory to the cheques of the accused company – Produced Ministry of Corporate Affairs record confirming he was never part of t...