Suit For Declaration Involves All Co-Owners; Limitation Plea Cannot Be Decided At Interlocutory Stage Of Impleadment: Telangana High Court Mere Proof Of Proper Dispatch Sufficient: Bombay High Court Says Trade Marks Registrar Need Not Prove Actual Delivery Of Renewal Notice Casteist Remarks Inside Private Office Without Independent Witnesses Do Not Attract SC/ST Act: Delhi High Court Private Property Transfer Not Void Under Section 64 CPC If Made Before 'Effective' Execution Of Attachment Warrant: Karnataka High Court Statement Under Section 164 CrPC Is Not Substantive Evidence, Cannot Be Sole Basis For Conviction When Victim Turns Hostile: Madras High Court Murder Simpliciter Is Not A Motor Accident; Claim Under Motor Vehicles Act Requires Causal Link Between Death And Vehicle: Supreme Court Mere Involvement Of Car In Chain Of Circumstances Leading To Death Doesn't Attract Motor Vehicles Act: Supreme Court Proclaimed Absconder Cannot Seek Quashing Of Criminal Proceedings Under Section 528 BNSS: Allahabad High Court Magistrate Cannot Mechanically Discharge Accused Without Recording Reasons Under Section 239 CrPC: Calcutta High Court Trial Courts Must Strictly Follow Mandate Of Section 43D(5) UAPA To Record Prima Facie Finding Before Granting Bail: Delhi High Court Executive Cannot Impose Additional Eligibility Criteria For Statutory Appointments Beyond What Is Prescribed In Parent Act: Karnataka High Court

"CRIMINAL LAW" Digest

Criminal Law - Motor Vehicle Accident – Rash and Negligent Driving – Sections 279 and 304(A) IPC – Conviction Set Aside – The accused was convicted by the Trial Court and the same was upheld by the First Appellate Court for allegedly causing death by rash and negligent driving – Held: Prosecution failed to establish rashness or negligence beyond reasonable doubt &ndas...

Criminal Law - Summoning of Additional Accused – Validity of Summons under Section 193 Cr.P.C. – Special Court Empowered – Petitioners were initially cited as witnesses but were summoned as accused after evaluation of the case record – Held: Summoning was within the jurisdiction of the Special Court and does not constitute second cognizance – Offence-based cognizance ...

Criminal Law  – Framing of Charges – Prima Facie Case Under IPC – Not Under PC Act – Allegation that appellant inserted forged notes above Minister’s signature to avoid newspaper publication of tenders – CFSL confirmed handwriting match – PWD Minister denied issuing such instructions – Held: Prima facie case exists under Sections 409 and 468 IPC...

Criminal Writ - Illegal Arrest – Grounds of Arrest Not Effectively Communicated – Violation of Article 22(1) – Petitioner alleged that accused was arrested without proper intimation of arrest grounds to relatives and in violation of constitutional rights – Held: Arrest must comply with Article 22(1), and grounds must be meaningfully conveyed – However, in present case...

PIL - Domestic Violence Act – Implementation of Statutory Duties – Section 6 to Section 11 of the Act – Directions Issued – The petitioner, a public interest organization, sought effective implementation of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – The Court found gaps in the appointment of Protection Officers, availability of shelter homes, medical a...

Criminal Law - Juvenile Justice Act – Determination of Age – School Certificate and Birth Certificate Take Precedence – The JJB had wrongly rejected documentary evidence and ordered medical examination despite availability of school and municipal birth records – Held: Section 94(2) of JJ Act mandates preference for documentary proof – Medical opinion can only be consi...

Criminal Law – Quashing - Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, and 120B of the IPC - Forgery Allegations – Absence of Material Linking Accused to Document Creation – Quashing Allowed – Petitioner accused of forging landlord’s signature on settlement letter to regain possession of shop post-eviction – Held: No prima facie material showing petitioner authored or procured ...

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences – Conviction under POCSO – Credibility of Child Witness – DNA and Medical Evidence – Aggravated Penetrative Sexual Assault – Appeal Dismissed. Penetrative Sexual Assault – Minor Victim – Appellant, maternal uncle of the survivor aged 5 years, convicted under Sections 376(2)/506 IPC and Section 6 read with Sect...

Criminal Law – Addition of Charge – Section 216 CrPC – Scope and Preconditions – Trial court allowed addition of Section 306 IPC charge against petitioner after examining prosecution witnesses under Section 216 CrPC – Held: While the court has exclusive power to alter or add charges, such power must be exercised only where materials on record disclose ingredients of t...

Criminal Law – Appeal Against Conviction - Demand and Acceptance – Prevention of Corruption Act – Conviction Set Aside – The complainant alleged that the appellants demanded ₹10,000 as bribe for facilitating land possession – Trap was allegedly conducted and bribe recovered from the Circle Officer – However, material witnesses including the two independent vil...