Rape on False Promise of Marriage – Whether Conviction Sustainable – The appellant was convicted for rape based on an alleged false promise of marriage—Trial Court found that the prosecutrix consented to sexual relations believing in the appellant’s promise—Held: Consent obtained under a misconception of fact due to a false promise of marriage is not valid under Secti...
Criminal Law – Rape of Minor Daughter – Conviction Under IPC and POCSO Act – Appellant convicted for raping his 9-year-old daughter – Trial Court sentenced him to life imprisonment under Sections 376(2)(f) and 376(2)(i) IPC and Sections 3/4 of POCSO Act – High Court modified the sentence to life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life – Supreme Court ...
Criminal Law – Bail Granted for Examination Fraud – State’s Appeal Against Bail – Respondents accused of engaging in a recruitment examination fraud by arranging a dummy candidate – Trial Court denied bail, citing serious disruption to the public examination system – Rajasthan High Court granted bail on grounds of lack of criminal antecedents, absence of appoint...
Criminal Law – Prevention of Corruption – Appeal Against Conviction – Appellant (Enforcement Inspector) convicted under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act for allegedly demanding and accepting a bribe for processing a trade license – Trial Court sentenced him to 1-year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,000 unde...
Maintenance – Right of Wife Despite Decree for Restitution of Conjugal Rights – Husband contended that wife voluntarily deserted him, making her ineligible for maintenance—Held: Mere passing of a decree for restitution of conjugal rights does not disentitle wife from maintenance unless husband proves willful desertion—Maintenance order upheld [Paras 6-9].
Quant...
Criminal Law - Will – Fraud and Undue Influence – Whether Execution Was Valid – The plaintiff-respondent challenged the Will executed by his father Lodhe in favor of the appellant—Trial court and appellate court found that the Will was obtained through fraud and undue influence, as the testator was ill, illiterate, and under the influence of alcohol—Held: Execution of...
Criminal Law – Employer’s Liability for Workplace Accident – No Prima Facie Case Under Section 304 IPC – Appellants engaged in interior decoration work were accused of causing death by negligence after two employees were electrocuted while working on a shop signboard – Prosecution alleged lack of safety measures such as rubber shoes and belts – Trial Court and H...
Criminal Law - POCSO Act – Disclosure of Minor Victim’s Identity – Media Responsibility – The petitioner, an editor of a news channel, was accused of revealing the identity of a minor victim and her family in a sexual offence case—Held: Publication of victim’s identity violates Section 23 of the POCSO Act—Media houses have an obligation to protec...
Quashing of FIR – Whether Complaints Were False and Motivated – The appellants, a married couple, challenged two FIRs filed against them in 2010 and 2011 for forgery, cheating, and criminal conspiracy—Held: Merely alleging that an FIR is false is insufficient for quashing—Both FIRs disclosed cognizable offences—No interference warranted at this stage [Paras 2-5].
&...
Criminal Law – Quashing - Prevention of Corruption – Demand and Acceptance of Bribe – Proof Required – Appeal Allowed - The appellant, a former Gujarat minister, was accused of corruption for allegedly granting fishing contracts without a tender process – The High Court upheld the criminal proceedings, but the Supreme Court held that no prima facie material indicated ...