Reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) – Eligibility for General Category – The petitioners argued that candidates from the EWS category who scored higher than the last candidate in the General Category should be considered for unreserved seats – Held: As per Article 16(6) of the Constitution, EWS reservation is distinct, and candidates selected under this category sh...
Right to Information Act – Disclosure of Candidate Marks – Petitioner, a candidate for Junior Clerk post, was denied information regarding marks obtained by other candidates on grounds of confidentiality under Maharashtra District Courts Right to Information (Revised Rules), 2009, and under Sections 8(1)(j) and 11 of RTI Act – Petitioner contended that public interest and transpa...
Service Law - Disciplinary Proceedings – Procedural Lapses – Quashing of Dismissal Order – The respondent, a storekeeper implicated in a misappropriation case involving government rations, was dismissed following departmental proceedings – The CAT found procedural deficiencies in the inquiry and set aside the dismissal, allowing for fresh proceedings – The High Court ...
Labour Law - Scope of the BOCW Act – Statutory Welfare Measures – Model Code of Conduct Implications – The Petition impugned a Circular dated 17 October 2023 issued by the Maharashtra Building and Other Construction Workers Welfare Board, which suspended registrations, renewals, and other welfare measures for construction workers based on the Model Code of Conduct for elections &...
Jurisdiction – Criminal Procedure – FIR Quashing – Petitioner challenged the jurisdiction of the CJM, Jammu, to entertain a complaint leading to FIR No.79/2013 – Contended no part of the cause of action arose within territorial jurisdiction of Jammu – Court held CJM lacked jurisdiction under Section 156(3) CrPC as no event occurred within its territorial limits &ndash...
Election Law – Cancellation of Elections – Impugned Order – The petitioner challenged the order dated 11.10.2024, which cancelled the elections for the post of Panch and Sarpanch of village Chak Haraj, Tehsil Mamdot, District Ferozepur – The petitioner argued that the order was illegal, arbitrary, and against natural justice – High Court held that the cancellation of ...
Electricity Law – Privatization of U.T. Chandigarh Electricity Wing – Validity of Bidding Process – The petitioners challenged the privatization process of the U.T. Chandigarh Electricity Wing, alleging that the transfer scheme under Section 131 of the Electricity Act, 2003, was neither finalized nor approved before the issuance of bids, and that no company was incorporated to un...
Proper Officer Jurisdiction – Section 6 and Section 5 of the Customs Act, 1962 – Jurisdiction of DRI Officers to Issue Notices – Canon India Clarified - The Supreme Court clarified that DRI officers had been validly empowered to issue show cause notices under Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962, by virtue of prior notifications and statutory provisions under Sections 2(34) and 5....
Arbitration Award - Stay of Execution - Section 36 of the Arbitration Act - The appellant challenged the High Court's order granting a stay of the arbitral award, conditional on furnishing a bank guarantee instead of requiring a deposit of the awarded amount - Held: Under Section 36(3), the Court should prioritize conditions to protect the decree-holder’s rights, generally requiring a de...
Civil Law – Partition and Family Property – Corporate Ownership and Ancestral Rights – Plaintiff sought partition of properties purchased in the name of the family-owned company, claiming they were joint family properties managed by the defendant – Court held that property registered under a company, even if family-owned, is not family property in legal terms; shareholder r...