Service Law – Promotion – Respondent's promotion withheld due to disciplinary action leading to 'censure' – Bank’s rules specify 'censure' as a minor penalty – Adoption of sealed cover procedure for respondent’s promotion due to pending disciplinary action – Supreme Court held that promotion recommendations in a sealed cover cannot be e...
Service Law – Retrospective Seniority – The High Court erroneously granted retrospective seniority to the respondent from 20.11.1985, a date when he was not borne in service – Respondent entered service only on 10.2.1996 following Supreme Court's direction – Jurisprudence in service law advises that retrospective seniority cannot be claimed from a date when an employee ...
Civil Procedure – Res Judicata – Section 92 CPC – Representative suit – Suit filed under Section 92 CPC for settling a scheme of administration for a mosque – Ownership of the suit property was an issue – Judgment in the representative suit is binding on all interested parties – Issue of title to the suit property determined in the representative suit bars...
Arbitration – MSMED Act – Jurisdiction and Procedure – Dispute regarding payment for supply of TMT bars – Facilitation Council dismissed proceedings citing lack of jurisdiction – High Court dismissed writ petition suggesting remedy under Section 34 of Arbitration Act – Supreme Court held Facilitation Council did not follow proper procedure under Section 18 of MS...
Negotiable Instruments Act – Dishonor of Cheque – Complaint under Section 138 of the NI Act for dishonor of cheque – Respondent issued cheque for Rs. 1,50,000 as part repayment of advance – Cheque dishonored due to insufficient funds – Magistrate convicted respondent, sentencing to six months imprisonment and fine – Sessions Court upheld conviction – High ...
Non-Release of Prisoners – Delay in Release after Bail – Suo moto proceedings initiated due to reports of non-release of prisoners post bail grant – Adoption of FASTER (Fast and Secured Transmission of Electronic Records) system proposed – Supreme Court directed ensuring internet facility in jails for electronic transmission of orders – Interim communication through S...
Stamp Duty – Refund – Application for refund of stamp duty – Appellant sought refund due to prolonged proceedings before NCDRC – Application rejected on grounds of delay beyond six months – Supreme Court held rejection of refund application due to judicial delay violates equity and fairness – Case fit for exercise of power under Article 142 of the Constitution &...
Electricity Duty – Imposition and Penalty – Appellant challenged imposition of electricity duty and penalty on supply of electricity to BSEB – High Court dismissed writ petition citing availability of alternate remedy and factual nature of dispute – Supreme Court held High Court erred in dismissing petition – Issues raised were questions of law suitable for writ juris...
Eviction – Unauthorized Subletting and Construction – Show cause notices issued to respondents for unauthorized subletting and construction – Orders of eviction passed and upheld by Additional District Judge – High Court allowed writ petitions challenging eviction – Supreme Court restored eviction orders – Unauthorized partnership and subletting violated license...
Education Law – Regulation of Service Conditions – State of UP amended Regulation 101 to mandate outsourcing for non-teaching Class IV staff in aided institutions – High Court found amendment unconstitutional for violating Article 14 – Supreme Court upheld validity of the regulation – Policy decisions concerning economic efficiency and financial constraints are within...