Examination – Re-evaluation of Answer Sheets – Absence of Provision – Petitioner requested re-evaluation of answer sheets for English language and Criminal Law papers in PCS (JB) 2019 – Court held that re-evaluation is not permitted in absence of relevant rules/instructions – Clause 11 of the advertisement explicitly disallowed re-evaluation – Petition dismissed...
Civil Procedure – Rejection of Plaint – Application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of suit on grounds of being barred by law due to previous suit dismissal under Order IX Rule 9 CPC – Court examines whether suit is barred by law solely based on plaint averments – Held, suit not manifestly barred; averments did not disclose the suit as barred by law without defens...
Civil Procedure - Appointment of Local Commissioner - Article 227 of Constitution - Order 26 Rule 9 CPC - Application to appoint local commissioner in execution proceedings dismissed by execution court - Held, physical demarcation necessary to determine encroachment - Local commissioner to be appointed to ascertain actual occupation of land - Civil revision maintainable where substantive rights ar...
Motor Accident Compensation – Assessment of Disability – The appellant, a pillion rider injured in a motor accident, was initially awarded compensation by the Tribunal, considering 25% disability. The High Court reduced this to 20% based on a re-assessment, leading to a reduction in the compensation amount. The Supreme Court reversed the High Court's reduction, reinstating the Trib...
Contract Law – Liability of Surety – Delay by Creditor – Public Auction – Petitioner stood as surety for contractor in a public auction – Contractor defaulted on payments – Petitioner argued that delay by State in taking action discharged the surety – Held, State's delay does not discharge surety's liability – Contract terms and provisions of...
Labour Law – Reinstatement vs. Compensation – Non-compliance with Section 25-F – Labour Court found termination invalid due to non-compliance with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act but denied reinstatement, awarding Rs. 1,20,000 as compensation – Held, compensation inadequate for 10 years of service – Following principles in similar cases, compensation incre...
Property Law – Auction Purchase – Free from Encumbrances – Petitioner purchased property in e-auction from bank with assurance of no encumbrances – Sale certificate issued, but registration refused due to property attachment for previous owner's dues – Held, rights of secured creditor have priority over government dues – Petitioner under no obligation to dis...
Benami Transactions – Prohibition – Order 7 Rule 11 CPC – Suit for declaration of ownership of property purchased in another's name, alleging fiduciary relationship – Application for rejection under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC dismissed – Held, legislature prohibited benami transactions, except in specified cases under Section 4(3) of the 1988 Act – Court to conside...
Service Law – Termination of Judicial Officer – Allegations of Illicit Relationship – Petitioner's service terminated based on allegations by another judicial officer's wife – No evidence supporting allegations – Held, termination based on unsubstantiated allegations is unjust – Petitioner's termination order quashed – Petitioner entitled to re...
Civil Procedure – Lifting the Veil – Courts’ Duty – Courts must make sincere attempts to lift the veil and expose any sinister design even in civil litigation – Decisions should not be perfunctory or cursory – Lower courts failed to scrutinize the motives behind the litigation. [Para 28]
Amendment of Pleadings – Original Pleadings’ Signi...