Service Law - Organised Group-A Service Status – Full Recognition of CAPFs as OGAS – DoPT OM Binding – High Court Error – The Court clarified that its earlier decision in Harananda (2019) was not limited to NFFU but affirmed full OGAS status for CAPFs – Held: Once declared OGAS, CAPFs must be treated as such for all cadre matters – High Court's failure to co...
Constitutional Law – Public Interest Litigation – Heritage Site Modification – Chandigarh Administration challenged High Court orders directing construction of verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 and laying of green paver blocks for parking – High Court issued writs of mandamus emphasizing public utility and sustainable development – Supreme Court upheld both direct...
Service Law – Absorption of Employees – Right to Pension – Functional Integration – Absorbed Employees Entitled to Pension – Absorbed employees from dissolved electricity co-operative societies claimed parity in pension benefits with regular MPSEB employees – Supreme Court held that once absorbed, these employees are entitled to pension under MPSEB from date of ...
Writ - Designation of Senior Advocates – Validity of Indira Jaising Guidelines – Guidelines Partially Overruled – Supreme Court revisits framework laid down in Indira Jaising-1 and Indira Jaising-2 – Held: 100-point assessment and interview system found unworkable and subjective – Paragraph 73.7 of Indira Jaising-1 deleted – New rule-based regime to be framed by...
Consumer Law – Flat Allotment Dispute – Execution of Agreement – MOFA – Supreme Court Upholds Alternate Flat Possession – Builder cancelled allotment despite part payment and failed to execute agreement – NCDRC directed execution with compensation, later apartment found alienated in violation of stay – Supreme Court allowed substitution with similar flat, ...
Arbitration Law - Statutory arbitration under SARFAESI Act - Scope of Section 11 – Statutory Arbitration Mandated – Interpretation of “any dispute relating to securitisation or reconstruction or non-payment” – Held: Section 11 of SARFAESI Act mandates arbitration for disputes between banks, financial institutions, ARCs, or qualified buyers where such disputes relate t...
Civil Writ - Land Transfer by Tribals – Validity of Rule 4(1)(a)(i), 1975 Rules – Challenge Dismissed – Petitioner challenged the prohibition on transfer of tribal land to non-tribals for agricultural use – High Court held that the restriction under Rule 4(1)(a)(i) requiring land to be used only for non-agricultural purposes post-transfer was constitutionally valid – ...
Civil Law - Title and Possession – Ownership Claim Based on Sale Deeds – Dismissal of Suit – Plaintiffs claimed ownership of 'B' schedule property as part of 'A' schedule property located in Sy. Nos. 28/1 and 28/2 – Trial Court found that western boundaries in the sale deeds consistently mentioned the existence of Makali-Yadalu road – Boundaries in sal...
Motor Accident Claim – Remarriage of Widow – Amendment Sought – Application Initially Dismissed – Revision Allowed – Petitioners in a motor accident claim sought amendment in written statement to plead remarriage of claimant-widow affecting her entitlement to compensation – Amendment denied by Tribunal – Held: Plea was supported by earlier cross-examinatio...
Pre-emption – Section 8 WBLR Act – Short Deposit of Consideration – Application Not Maintainable – Petitioners filed application to pre-empt land transferred by three sale deeds, but deposited only half of the total consideration—Held: As per statutory mandate and binding precedent, entire consideration with 10% must be deposited at the time of application—Failu...