Civil Procedure – Advocate Commissioner – Identification of Land – Appointment Set Aside – Trial court permitted appointment of Advocate Commissioner to identify suit land in Sy.No.125/E3 at the instance of the plaintiff relying on a sada bainama lacking boundary descriptions – High Court held that such appointment at preliminary stage amounted to collection of eviden...
SC/ST Act – Anticipatory Bail – Bar Under Section 18 – Prima Facie Case – Appellant sought pre-arrest bail in FIR alleging public insult of complainant belonging to Scheduled Caste by using caste-based slurs – Held: Prima facie, allegations attract Section 3(1)(r) of SC/ST Act – Abuse was specific, caste-based, and made in public view while complainant was disch...
Motor Accident Claim – Proof of Income – Summoning Income Tax Records – Petitioners (legal heirs of deceased) sought summoning of Clerk of Income Tax Department and employer’s salary records to prove deceased’s income – Tribunal rejected application – Held: Petitioners failed to produce even basic bank account statement of deceased – Claimed salary p...
Civil Procedure – Execution of Decree – Civil Imprisonment – Order 21 Rule 37 CPC – Judgment-debtor ordered to be detained in civil prison for 3 months for non-payment of decretal amount of ₹7,06,177 – Petitioner argued non-compliance with Section 51 CPC and lack of opportunity to show cause – Held: Sufficient opportunity was provided; petitioner failed to fur...
SARFAESI Act – Availability of Statutory Remedy – Maintainability of Writ Petition – Borrower filed writ petition seeking installment facility and return of possession of mortgaged property – Learned Single Judge permitted repayment in installments and ordered return of possession upon part payment – Held: Writ petition not maintainable as borrower had not challenged ...
Municipal Law – Trade Licence – Renewal – Firecrackers Sale – Petitioners operated licensed firecracker business since 1983 and maintained separate storage since 2001 – Respondent City Municipal Council refused renewal of trade licences citing absence of fire department NOC and location in densely populated area – Held: No provision in law requiring NOC from fir...
Civil Writ - Service Law – Suspension – Rule 10 of KCS (CCA) Rules – Petitioner, a Panchayat Development Officer, suspended based on a video clip allegedly showing him accepting illegal gratification – Suspension order issued by Disciplinary Authority based on communication from CEO – Tribunal declined interim relief – High Court held that suspension under Rule ...
PIL - Wildlife Law – Possession of Ivory – Notification under Section 40(4) of Wild Life Protection Act – Gazette Publication Mandatory – State issued notifications permitting declaration of ivory articles by a film actor and granted ownership certificates – Notifications not published in the Official Gazette – Held: Power under Section 40(4) must be exercised s...
Service Law – Dismissal of Bank Officer – Alleged Fraudulent Bond Transaction – Disciplinary Proceedings – Judicial Review – Petitioner, a Chief Manager with an unblemished record, dismissed after internal disciplinary proceedings found him guilty of diverting ₹5,00,000 by issuing a false RBI Bond in the name of a customer – Petitioner claimed the act was a pr...
Hindu Law – Inheritance – Applicability of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 – Married Daughter’s Right – Plaintiff sought declaration of title and partition of ancestral property inherited by her brother after their father's death – Both Courts below found that father died in 1950-51, prior to enactment of 1956 Act – Held: Succession opened under pre-1956 Mi...