Jai Hind – Let us Live United with Nature” Remark Deemed Relevant by Madurai High Court in TNPSC Examination Case
In a significant judgment, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court today ruled in favor of a petitioner whose essay answer was previously invalidated by the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission (TNPSC). The case revolved around the petitioner’s use of the phrase “Jai Hind, Let us live united with nature” in a TNPSC examination essay, which the Commission had deemed irrelevant and impertinent, leading to the invalidation of her answer paper.
Justice Battu Devanand, presiding over the case, observed that the petitioner’s concluding remark in the essay was “very relevant and appropriate to the question” and that such writing “cannot be treated as impertinent remarks or to give some indication to the examiner about her identity.” This pivotal observation underscored the judgment which has now set a precedent for how examination bodies evaluate answer scripts.
The petitioner had approached the court challenging the TNPSC’s decision to invalidate her essay answer in the Combined Civil Services Examination-II Group-II Services. She argued that her conclusion was highly pertinent to the essay’s topic on the importance and conservation of natural resources.
The Court’s decision was rooted in a broad interpretation of relevance and patriotism in academic responses. “For development and prosperity of the country, the conservation of natural resources is very essential and important,” Justice Devanand noted in his judgment. He further added, “While writing an essay, on the issue of importance and conservation of natural resources, at conclusion writing as ‘Jai Hind – Let us live united with nature’ by the petitioner is very relevant.”
The ruling has directed the TNPSC to re-evaluate the petitioner’s answer paper and consider her for the respective position, should she meet the necessary criteria. This decision has been hailed as a landmark judgment, emphasizing the importance of contextual interpretation and the role of patriotism in academic discourse.
Date of Decision: 06.11.2023
M.Kalpana VS The Secretary
