Required Proof of Shared Common Object: High Court Upholds Acquittal in Unlawful Assembly and Murder Case
In a significant ruling, the High Court of Punjab and Haryana has dismissed an appeal against the acquittal of respondents Gurpreet Kaur and Gopal Ram in a case involving the death of the complainant’s son. The Bench, comprising Justices Sudhir Singh and Harsh Bunger, emphasized the importance of establishing a shared common object among members of an unlawful assembly for conviction under Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
The key legal point addressed in this judgement was the role of individual members in an unlawful assembly under Section 149 of the IPC. The court underscored that mere presence at the scene, especially without weapons, does not suffice to prove membership or common intent in the unlawful assembly.
The case stemmed from an incident on August 15, 2017, where the complainant’s son and another individual were allegedly attacked by an unlawful assembly, leading to the son’s death. The respondents were acquitted by the trial court, leading the State of Punjab to appeal the decision.
The High Court’s assessment was comprehensive:
Eyewitness Testimony: The court critically assessed the eyewitness accounts, noting the absence of evidence indicating the use of weapons by the acquitted accused.
Application of Section 149 IPC: The judgment referenced the Supreme Court’s decision in Allauddin Mian Vs. State of Bihar to clarify the application of Section 149, emphasizing that individual acts post-frustration of the common object do not implicate other members.
Appeal Against Acquittal Principles: The High Court outlined the principles for appellate intervention in acquittal cases, stressing the need for ‘compelling and substantial reasons’ to overturn an acquittal.
The High Court upheld the trial court’s decision, dismissing the application for leave to appeal. The respondents were acquitted based on the lack of evidence showing their active participation or common intent in the alleged crime.
Date of Decision: 15th February 2024
STATE OF PUNJAB VS GURPREET KAUR & ANR.
